ABORTION NEWS
From 2002-JULY to SEPT.

Sponsored link.

Background information on many aspects of abortion is found in individual essays, e.g. public opinion, clinic protests, clinic violence, parental notification,
abortion methods, and post abortion
syndrome. Information about the
use of stem cells is elsewhere.

News items:
 | 2002-JUL-2: USA: Alleged appointee to CDC head selected:
The Family Research Council, a fundamentalist Christian group, expressed
regret at the apparent new appointee to head the Centers for Disease Control.
They speculate that Dr. Julie Gerberding will be shortly appointed by President
Bush. They note that she has, in the past, supported safe-sex education
so that students who decide to become sexually active will know how to
minimize their chances of STD transmission. She has also supported
supplying emergency contraceptives in schools to female students who
have had unprotected sex and may otherwise become pregnant. 1
Dr. Dobson of Focus on the Family also weighed in against Dr. Gerberding.
More details. |
 | 2002-JUL-9: USA: President Bush breaks promise: According to
the American Life League, (ALL) when George W. Bush was running
for president, the U.S. conference of Catholic Bishops asked him
whether he would oppose research on aborted fetuses. He replied: "I
oppose using federal funds to perform fetal tissue research from induced
abortions." Again, according to the ALL, he "quietly approved a
decision made by members of his administration to endow federal money to
a project at Johns Hopkins University involving research on aborted
human embryos up to eight weeks old..." 2 |
 | 2002-JUL-23: World: President Bush redirects grant: The U.S.
Congress had allocated up to $34 million in aid to support international
family planning programs administered by the United Nations
Population Fund (UNFPA). President Bush withheld these funds because
a small part of the UNFPA's total efforts deals with China. Sometimes,
China forces women to have abortions or to undergo sterilization against
their will in order to enforce the country's one-child policy. President
Bush has redirected the funding to the USAID Child Survival and
Health Program Fund. As the name implies, the mandate of this agency
is to improve children's health. One small part of their program
involves money "forecasting, purchasing, and supplying contraceptive
commodities and other materials necessary for reproductive health
programs." One small part of those supplies involve
emergency contraception. Physicians regard
this medication as a form of contraception, since once a pregnancy has
begin, the pills have no effect. However, some pro-life groups like the
American Life League considers them to be "abortion-inducing
chemicals that kill the very children that the fund claims to help."
The League accused President Bush of stabbing "them in the
back." 3 According to The Guardian, a UK
newspaper, the European Union has decided to replace the UNFPA funding
with 32 million euros -- the equivalent of about $34 million U.S. dollars. |
 | 2002-AUG-3: PA: Boyfriend obtains injunction preventing woman
from having an abortion: John Stachokus, 27, of Plains, PA, obtained
an injunction on JUL-29 that prevented his girlfriend, Tanya Meyers, 22,
of Kingston, PA, from having an abortion. She was nine weeks pregnant.
She wanted to have an abortion because of verbal and emotional abuse,
threats and harms that she allegedly claimed her ex-boyfriend put her
through. Oral arguments were heard on JUL-31. Her boyfriend allegedly
said that she wants the abortion "out of spite and hatred." Lawyers on both sides have been
given to at least AUG-5 to file written arguments. Meyers' lawyers filed
an emergency appeal on AUG-1 seeking to overturn the original
injunction, which had been put in place by Judge Thomas F. Burke, Jr. of
the Court of Common Pleas in Wilkes-Barre, PA. Some reactions:
 | Linda Rosenthal of the Center for Reproductive Law and Policy
wrote "The lower court's injunction shows complete disregard
for legal precedent. No person....has the right to veto an adult
woman's decision to terminate her first-trimester pregnancy." 4
Later, she said: "An adult woman has a fundamental constitutional
right to privacy. There is no excuse for what happened in Pennsylvania
this past week." 5 |
 | Dianna Thompson, of the American Coalition for Fathers and
Children, said that, to her knowledge, this case is unique. "It
could be historic and have real implications for men and women
everywhere" |
 | Elizabeth Cavendish, of the National Abortion and Reproductive
Rights Action League said: "It's important because people need
to be reminded that this kind of harassment of women still goes on.
The fact that this case even happened, let alone what the outcome will
be, has ramifications. That judge was wrong. It's a matter of law. The
Supreme Court of our nation has ruled it is unconstitutional to allow
a husband to stop his pregnant wife from having a wanted abortion. So
it goes without saying that boyfriends and ex-boyfriends don't get
veto power either." She added: "Judges are not supposed to
grant injunctions unless the applicant can reasonably show they're
likely to succeed in the lawsuit," she said. "There is no way this man
can win this case." 4 |
 | Sylvia Law, who teaches constitutional and family law at New York
University, said: "A lot of issues in this area are, honestly,
difficult. This is not one of them. This is crystal clear. The law on
the question of fathers' or husbands' capability to veto a woman's
ability to have an abortion has always been that it's completely
unconstitutional." |
 | Al Rende, founder of Fathers for Life, said that men should
have a say in the outcome of a pregnancy they helped to create. He
said: "Dads need to have support. The community needs to get behind
what's happening here. Our community can help influence national
policy and law. Our judges can only do what the laws allow them to do." |
The judge, Michael Conohan, later cancelled the injunction. He said
that the U.S. Supreme Court ruling in Roe v. Wade (and other rulings) require that
neither an ex-boyfriend nor a fetus has standing to
interfere with a woman's choice to terminate her pregnancy. He cited numerous court
rulings that have rejected similar attempts to prevent
women from exercising their right to obtain an abortion. Conohan said: "The
balance of the equities weights heavily in favor of Meyers. The delay in
her procedure has inflicted significant and extreme emotional distress
on Meyers, and she faces increased medical risks due to the delay in the
procedure. Furthermore, the denial of her constitutional right to
effectuate her abortion decision is in itself immediate and irreparable
harm." 5 John Stachokus plans to file an appeal
with the state Superior Court on AUG-12.
This is
a situation in which either the woman wins and is allowed to have the
abortion that she wants, or the man wins and she is
required to continue with the pregnancy and give birth to a newborn that
she does not want. A win-win situation is not possible. |
 | 2002-AUG-5: USA: President Bush signs "Born-alive Infants
Protection Act: This law requires that a fetus that is delivered
alive as a result of an abortion must be given medical attention;
physicians must attempt to preserve its life. The law will have no real
effect on the eventual outcome of more than 99% of all abortions --
those performed in the first two trimesters of pregnancy. That is
because the fetus at that state of development has no chance of living
outside of the woman's womb. In essence, the law says that even though a
woman may have a right, under unusual circumstances, to a late-term
abortion, she has no right to be guaranteed a dead baby. The senate passed this law on JUL-18. The president signed it into law on
AUG-5. 6 |
 | 2002-AUG-14: OH: Rolling billboards show graphic pictures of
aborted fetuses: A group of trucks
sponsored by the Center for Bio-Ethical Reform toured
through Akron and Canton OH this week. Extremely graphic photographs of
aborted fetuses were displayed on their sides and back. The Center's
Midwestern region executive director, Mark
Harrington, said: "Our experience is that most people, when they see
the trucks, react the way that we want, which is shock or dismayed
They're very disturbed by it, and they should be disturbed.'' The
Center have stated that the fetuses are from first trimester abortions.
However, in previous displays of this type, only the extremely rare late
abortions have been shown. Roberta Aber, executive director of Planned
Parenthood of Summit, Portage and Medina counties, said that these "extreme''
displays alienate people rather than winning them over...."Reasoned
debate about abortion is always in order. But when you're dealing with
people who will resort to these kinds of unreasonable tactics, then it's
too bad any of us have to waste our time dealing with it.'' Dr.
Lolita M. McDavid, medical director of child advocacy and protection at
Rainbow Babies and Children's Hospital in Cleveland noted that
young children could be frightened and disturbed by these graphic
images. She said: "I don't think that children should be subjected to
anything that's scary that they cannot process. Whenever you do
something that's very frightening to someone who doesn't have the
ability to process it, it's an abusive act.'' 7 |
 | 2002-AUG-15: CA: Bill to protect
abortion access. The Reproductive Privacy Act, passed
the Senate earlier in August and is being considered by the Assembly. It
forbids the state to "deny or interfere with a woman's fundamental
right to bear a child or to choose or obtain an abortion." The bill
is sponsored by Senator Sheila Kuehl (LA-D). She is concerned that the
Supreme Court might make some major change to Roe v. Wade. She said, "We
have an anti-choice president, an anti-choice Congress, and a Supreme
Court that's one vote away from overturning Roe v. Wade....Now is the
time to protect our right to choose." 8 |
This essay continues below.

Sponsored link:

 | 2002-AUG-16: FL: Tightening adoption laws probably increase
abortions: A new law in Florida requires women who cannot identify
the father of the child that they are placing in adoption must take out
a notice in the local paper where the child was conceived, advertising
her full name, physical details, and the dates and locations of sexual
activities that could have led to the pregnancy. The law was intended to
allow the men to realize that they have fathered a child so that they
could assert their parental rights if they wished to. Apparently, none
of the legislators considered the impact of the bill on the woman. As
the Family Research Council says: "...the law goes overboard.
Requiring moms to print their sexual history in the paper will deter
women from the adoption option and will likely drive them to consider
abortion." 9 |
 | 2002-AUG-19: WA: Navy loses abortion funding case: "Jane
Doe" is the wife of a sailor and is more than 21 weeks pregnant. The
fetus that she is carrying has anencephaly and lacks a forebrain (the
front part of the brain), cerebellum (the thinking part of the brain),
and cranium. It only has a brain stem. This is sometimes called the
reptilian brain, because it has not significantly changed since human
ancestors were reptiles. The fetus is, in essence, a reptile brain in a
human fetal body. Most infants with anencephaly die before birth. If
born alive, it will be blind, deaf, unconscious and unable to feel pain
or sense anything in the environment. It would never gain consciousness,
and would die within a few hours after birth. The longest life
expectancy is about a week. Fortunately, it will not feel pain as it is
dying.
Tricare, the Navy's health plan, only pays for abortions if they are
necessary to save the life of a woman. Anencephaly, the disorder that is
affecting the fetus, is specifically referred to in a law that prohibits
the federal government from funding an abortion. The operation will cost
about $2,500 to $3,000 which is beyond the financial ability of the
couple. In early August, a federal judge in Seattle ruled that
Tricare must fund the abortion. The government appealed. A two judge
panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco
denied the appeal. The abortion was scheduled to be performed during the
week of AUG-18. |
 | 2002-AUG-23: CA: Abortion education bill passes legislature:
Bill AB 2194 passed the California Assembly in MAY and passed the Senate
during the week of AUG-17. It is now awaiting Governor Davis' expected
signature. If signed, it will require all accredited medical schools in
the state to train OB/GYN residences in abortion procedures. Judie
Brown, president of the pro-life American Life League, opposes
the bill. She said: "The Governor of California is alleged to
represent all the people of his state, but if he signs this bill, he
will be executing a death sentence on the most vulnerable Californians."
She is referring to embryos and fetuses. Others claim that since
abortions are legal and sometimes necessary to save the life of a woman,
that a OB/GYN specialist is not fully trained unless s/he is capable of
performing an abortion procedure. 10 |
 | 2002-SEP-23: SC: Court rules that abortion clinic must provide
religious counseling: The 4th U.S. Circuit Court of
Appeals ruled that a South Carolina law is constitutional. It
requires abortion clinics to provide women access to counseling by
clergy upon request. |

References:
- Ken Connor, "CDC pick strikes sour note," Washington Update,
from the Family Research Council, 2002-JUL-2.
- "Bush Advances Legacy Of Bad Decisions, Broken Promises And Dead
Babies," American Life League National Desk, 2002-JUL-8, at:
http://www.usnewswire.com/topnews/first/0709-102.html
- "Redirection of $34 million from UNFPA to USAID a 'stab in the
back,' " American Life League, 2002-JUL-23, at:
http://www.all.org/news/020723.htm
- Jennifer Henn, "Nation watching Wilkes-Barre abortion case,"
ScrantonTimes.com at:
http://www.zwire.com/site/news.cfm?
- Denise Allabaugh, "Man can't stop abortion," Scranton Times
Tribune, 2002-AUG-6, at:
http://www.zwire.com/site/news.cfm?
- Ken Connor, "Live and Let Live: President Signs Born Alive Act,"
Family Research Council Washington Update for 2002-AUG-5.
- Cheryl Powell, "Abortion photo tour hits Akron," The Beacon
Journal, 2002-AUG-14, at:
http://www.ohio.com/mld/beaconjournal/3860605.htm
- Sean Scully, "Bill to bar abortion rollback," The Washington
Times, 2002-AUG-15, at:
http://www.washtimes.com/national/
- "Florida follows scarlet letter of the law," Family Research
Council, Washington Update, 2002-AUG-16.
- "California Governor Davis' Signature Would Train Medical Students
to Kill," American Life League, U.S. Newswire, 2002-AUG-23.


Copyright © 2002 & 2004 by the Ontario Consultants on
Religious Tolerance
Created: 2002-JUL-2
Latest update: 2004-JAN-10
Author: B.A. Robinson


|