This survey shows how difficult it is to interpret public polls. The vote of a person who knows little about the topic is counted just as much as an expert. Assuming that the results for question 5 and 6 were reported correctly it is obvious that many people believe that the fetus can survive outside of the womb during the first trimester. In fact, it is only in the third trimester that the fetus becomes viable.
And they would both be right. The question: "Do you favor or oppose abortion in the following circumstances?" is a curious query for a public opinion poll because of its ambiguity:
Many women would reject having an abortion themselves, even as they insist on the right of other women to have a choice.
Louis Harris Poll of 1996-AUGThis is an important poll because the same question has been asked of a representative sample of adults from 1973 to the present time. They typically ask the opinion of about 1,000 adults. Thus, the data from this poll can be used to track trends in public opinion as it shifts through time.
"THIRD AGE" Poll of 1998-JANThe Third Age refers to "the new, extended period of active adulthood which starts in the early 50s. It is characterized by a sense of accomplishment and fresh beginnings for individuals who champion a new view of what it means to be older." They conduct about two voluntary polls a month from among Internet users. 1 In late 1998-JAN to early FEB, they conducted a poll on the topic of abortion. Their somewhat loaded statement was: "I agree with the pro-life movement. Abortion is wrong and deserves criminal penalties." The surfer is asked whether they strongly agree, agree, are undecided, disagree or strongly disagree with that statement. As one might anticipate, their 2,684 responses were highly polarized on the topic.
This poll does have some weaknesses:
But it does suggest that North Americans are highly polarized on the topic of abortion access, and that any resolution to the conflict is not going to be a simple or speedy task. This essay continues below.
New York Times/ CBS Poll of 1998This poll was conducted on the 25th anniversary of the 1973 Supreme Court "Roe v. Wade" decision. This ruling established abortion on request during the first trimester, and allowed states to place increasing restrictions on access to abortion in the second and third trimester. Results of the poll were:
This is obviously a topic where people have strong opinions. The percentage of undecided respondents was 1% for men and 3% for women - an unusually low number for public opinion polls. The poll does not appear to be well structured. Respondents were not given the option of preferring the liberalization of abortion laws. Also, the "prohibit abortions" did not differentiate between those who wish to stop all abortions, and those who wish to criminalize all abortions except cases of rape, incest or where the woman's life is in danger from a continued pregnancy. A better series of options might be:
But even a series of 5 questions would not really generate an accurate picture of public attitude towards abortion. A further improvement would be to differentiate between early and late abortions. Perhaps the above series of 5 questions could be asked for abortions in each of the trimester. It is probable that some of the "increase restrictions" responses were a reaction to the recent debate over "Partial Birth Abortions." There appears to be a great deal of public opposition to this procedure. This may have motivated some clients to switch from the status quo to advocating restrictions.
Reference used:
Copyright © 1996 to 2006 by
Ontario Consultants on Religious Tolerance |
Custom Search
. | |
|
Page Translator:
