ABORTION ACCESS:
Public opinion nationwide poll
among youth on abortion access

Sponsored link.

2005 Poll:
Essentially all public opinion polls are conducted among adults. However, Professor Dennis Gilbert and students from his public opinion polling
class at Hamilton College conducted a "Hot Button Issues Poll" in 2005-NOV, with the help of Zogby International. They sampled
the opinion of one thousand randomly selected U.S. high school seniors by phone.
They asked questions related to homosexuality, including same-sex
marriage, abortion access, and gun control in 2005. The margin of error is ± 3%.
The poll found that the seniors' attitudes are quite liberal in two areas.
On abortion as a personal option, they seem to be quite conservative:
 | 70% of female students said they would not consider having an abortion
if they became pregnant. |
 | 67% of males students said they would not encourage their partner to
have an abortion if they became pregnant. |
On abortion as a personal option for others, they were also quite
conservative:
 | 54% felt that a pregnant student should give birth and give the baby up
for adoption |
 | 26% suggested that she should give birth and raise the baby. |
 | 13% suggested abortion |
 | 7% were unsure or gave no opinion. |
On related matters:
 | About 50% of female students know someone -- presumably a fellow student
-- who has had an abortion |
 | About 36% of male students know a person who had an abortion. |
When is abortion OK: The poll was far more complete than similar polls
among adults. They proposed various scenarios and asked whether they supported a
woman's right to choose to have an abortion:
 | 88.9% supported a woman's right to choose if the pregnancy was a serious
threat to her health. |
 | 80.9% if the pregnancy was the result of rape. |
 | 49.2% if the woman was under 18 and unmarried. |
 | 48.2% if the baby would probably have a serious birth defect. |
 | 39.8% if the family was poor and could not afford another child. |
 | 28.5% if the woman was married and didn't want another child. |
 | Fewer than 20% of students supported the right to abortion in all six
scenarios. |
Support for abortion access as a function of religious belief:
 | 32% of "born again" students supported a woman's access to abortion in
most or all cases. |
 | 52% of "other Protestants" agreed. |
 | 51% of Roman Catholics agreed. |
 | 70% of adherents of other religions agreed. |
 | 80% of those with no religious affiliation agreed |
 | 68% of those attending religious services from 0 to 3 times a month
agreed |
 | 38% of those attending religious services 4 or more times a month
agreed. |
In contrast:
 | 62% favored retaining the U.S. Supreme Court's 1973 decision to legalize
abortion access. |
 | About half described themselves as "pro-choice" |
 | About half said that abortion should be legal in all or almost all cases
(54% males; 52% females). |
 | Two in three would require parental permission for a minor to receive an
abortion. |

Interpretation:
The pollsters commented:
"National polls conducted by media organizations and university
researchers reveal that about 50 percent of adults would describe themselves
as “pro-choice” and more than 60 percent say they would not want to see the
Roe v. Wade decision overturned. But the majority also regards abortion as
morally wrong and would not concede a woman’s legal right to abortion except
in extreme circumstances, such as rape or significant threat to the health
of the mother. This is precisely the inconsistent, conservative leaning
pattern we have found in the Class of 2006."
Both adults and high school seniors appear to agree with the pro-life
movement that abortion as an immoral act, except perhaps under very unusual
circumstances. Yet they simultaneously describe themselves as pro-choice
What is not know is how many of the 70% of female students would stated
that they would not personally have an abortion would follow this
stance if they actually became pregnant. Some people's opposition to
abortion melts under certain circumstances when they are faced with an unwanted
pregnancy. For example, it is general knowledge among physicians that the vast
majority of parents elect to have an abortion in the event that the fetus is
found to have a serious birth defect.

References:
-
"Hamilton College National Youth Polls," Hamilton College, 2006-JAN,
at:
http://www.hamilton.edu/ You may need software to read this PDF file. It can
be obtained free from:


Copyright © 2006 by
Ontario Consultants on Religious Tolerance
Latest update: 2006-NOV-15
Author: B.A. Robinson


|