What are they?
When were they written?
Where are they now?
Do Christians follow them?
Should everyone follow them?
Part 1 of three parts
What are the Ten Commandments?
The Ten Commandments (a.k.a. Decalogue) are a listing of some of the
most important of the 613 mitzvot (God's behavioral rules) in the Hebrew Scriptures (a.k.a. Old Testament). Jewish tradition teaches that they were written by God on sapphire rocks
Within Judaism, they have historically been
accepted as a summary of the most important ten rules of
behavior which God expects all Jews to follow. The Torah records that God gave
the Decalogue to Moses on Mount Sinai, inscribed on stone tablets, and
the intended for the guidance of the ancient Hebrews. They form a small but
vital part of the total of 613 laws in the Hebrew Scriptures.
Within Christianity, the Decalogue has traditionally been
regarded as the foundational laws to which all Christians are to conform.
Most Christians continue to hold them in high regard, even though they have
rejected most of the other laws in the Mosaic Code as no longer
applicable to or binding on them. Examples of the latter are following strict behavior rules on the Sabbath (Saturday), prohibition of the eating of pork, shell fish, etc., prohibition of tattoos, a man engaged in sexual behavior with a woman during her menses, allowing disabled persons to be admitted to religious services, allowing women to be ordained, requiring a female victim of rape to marry her rapist, allowing human slavery, etc.
Within Islam, the religion's holy book -- the Qur'an
-- appears to refer to the
Decalogue and to urge that they be followed; however it does not contain the actual text:
007.145 "And We ordained laws for him in the tablets in all
matters, both commanding and explaining all things, (and said): 'Take
and hold these with firmness, and enjoin thy people to hold fast by the
best in the precepts'..."
The term "Decalogue" or "Decalog" is derived from the
Middle English "decaloge" which comes from the Latin "decalogus,"
which in turn originates from the Greek "dekalogus." "Deka" in Greek
There are three versions of the Decalogue mentioned in the Hebrew Scriptures
(a.k.a. Old Testament). All are different. They are at:
Exodus 20:2-17. This version in is by far the most commonly cited.
Depending upon how Ten Commandments are interpreted, the Exodus 20
version contain a total of 19
to 25 separate instructions. These have been traditionally sorted into ten
groups. Unfortunately, various faith groups sort them differently. This makes
inter-faith dialog difficult at times, and can cause conflicts over which
version of the Decalogue is to be accepted, displayed, and followed. A comparison of the Jewish, Catholic and Protestant versions are listed in the hebrew4christians.com web site. 1
When were the Ten Commandments written?
The Hebrew Scriptures describe the Ten Commandments as having been written by God during the Exodus of Jews from Egypt. Unfortunately, the name of the Pharaoh under which the Exodus occurred is not stated in the Scriptures. Dates of the Exodus from the 15th to the 13th Century BCE have been suggested. However, most present-day archeologists believe that the Exodus, as described in the Bible, never happened.
Some have suggested that the Ten Commandments were derived from earlier Hittite writings during the 14th to 12th century BCE.
Archaeologists Israel Finkelstein and Neil Asher Silberman argue for a seventh century BCE origin.
David H. Aaron has suggested sometime after 586 BCE. 2
Where are the two rocks containing the original Ten Commandments now?
The Hebrew Scriptures state that original tablets were broken by Moses when he found that his people had abandoned Yahweh, had built a golden calf, and had adopted ancient Egyptian pagan behavior. Later, God had Moses create two new tablets onto which God inscribed the words of the Commandments.
Some believe that the:
second set of Ten Commandments that Moses carried down from Mount Sinai, along with:
a jar of manna -- a food that God provided to the ancient Hebrews during their exodus from Egypt, and
the staff that belonged to Aaron the High Priest, and
a jar of oil to anoint the High Priest of the Third Temple -- if and when it is rebuilt --
all still exist and are located at an unknown location in an underground passage somewhere under the Temple Mount in Jerusalem. 3
Do Christians follow the Ten Commandments?
Although the Ten Commandments are held in high respect by many Christians,
two of them are routinely broken by some Christian denominations -- at least
if they are interpreted literally:
The prohibition against "any graven image, or any likeness of any
thing...," if interpreted literally, would seem to forbid a wide
range of objects, including a statue in a church, a cross, a crucifix,
or even to a photograph or drawing of a person. However, many denominations do not
interpret this passage in isolation or do not interpret it literally.
This allows Eastern Orthodox churches to
display icons. Roman Catholic cathedrals generally contains
statues. Many Protestant churches contain drawings and/or
photographs, even if only on their pamphlets and books.
Reserving the Sabbath (Saturday) as a day of rest. The vast majority
of churches have their main services on Sunday. Only Sabbatarian
denominations, like the Seventh Day Adventists and
Seventh Day Baptists,
have services on Saturday.
Should everyone follow all of the Ten Commandments?
The U.S. is the most religiously diverse
country in the world. Southern Ontario in Canada is regarded as the most
religiously diverse region of any country in the world. Both nations share a legacy of
religious freedom and religious tolerance. The U.S. Supreme Court has interpreted
the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution as requiring a complete separation of church and state.
Canadian culture largely separates church and state by tradition.
Ten Commandments were created within an entirely different culture with very
different expectations of its citizens. It was a ancient Hebrew theocracy where church and
state were blended. Everyone was expected to follow the state religion. A person
proselytizing a different faith among the ancient Hebrews could find themselves sentenced
to death as proscribed in the Hebrew Scriptures.
This culture clash has produced criticisms of some of the commandments within the Decalogue:
The first commandment requires that no god other than Yahweh is to be
worshipped. This is in open conflict with the "first freedom" in the U.S.
and Canada. This is religious freedom which allows people to freely believe, or to refuse to believe, in any specific God, Goddess, or a pantheon of Gods and Goddesses. Since the attributes assigned to God within Judaism, Islam, Christianity and other theistic religions differ significantly, following the first commandment would ban freedom of belief, freedom of speech, freedom of religious assembly, freedom of proselytizing, etc. by followers of different religions.
The second commandment, interpreted literally, punishes a person's
children, grandchildren, great-grandchildren and perhaps even great-great
grandchildren if the person has sinned by serving other Gods. Scapegoating, the transfer of the
responsibility for one person's sin onto innocent other people was common
in the ancient Middle East. However, most contemporary ethical systems --
both secular and religious -- prohibit scapegoating. Modern ethical systems hold a person responsible only for their own
actions. Punishing innocent children for deeds performed by their parents or more distant ancestors is widely considered a profoundly immoral act. Similarly, holding an entire group responsible for an evil deed of one member or a small sub-group of that group is profoundly immoral by most moral and ethical systems.
The fifth commandment requires that children honor their parents. Many
would feel that it is unreasonable to require a child to honor a parent who
was a sexual molester, a physical abuser, was guilty of neglect, or had abandoned their children.
There are two problems associated with the tenth commandment:
It treats women as pieces of property, and
It condones slavery. The terms "manservant" and "maidservant" in the
King James Version of the Bible do not refer to butlers and maids; they refer to male and female slaves.
Equal treatment and freedoms for men and women form an integral part of the beliefs and teachings of many religious
groups and secularists.
Essentially all North American religious groups reject the
concept of owning another human being in a state of slavery.
Thus, many would consider Commandments 1,2,5, and 10 to be deficient in terms of modern ethical and religious criteria. Some might suggest that the four Commandments should be retired from service, leaving only 7 commandments to be followed.