The final abolition of human
slavery in Christian countries
Sponsored link.
During the early 19th century,
Methodists in the state of Georgia followed John Wesley's lead and condemned
slavery.
Wesleyans:
"... learned to subdue
their critique, in order to grow in membership...Unlike Calvinist intellectuals
such as Charles Colcock Jones, Methodists rarely used the Old Testament
patriarchs and their hierarchical values to buttress the pro-slavery case.
Relying mainly on the letters attributed to Paul, Georgia Wesleyans argued that
slavery was scripturally allowable, but not necessarily ideal.In the
ante-bellum era their theoretical position was neither proslavery nor
antislavery, but neutrality. Christians lived in an imperfect world where
slavery was sanctioned by law; therefore, the church should coexist with
slavery, just as it did in Paul's day." 1
1800 +: The Roman Catholic church's Sacred Congregation of the
Index continued to place many anti-slavery tracts on their Index of Forbidden
Books in order to prevent the public from reading them.
1807: The first black Methodist church, the African Union
Church, was incorporated in Wilmington DE.
1808: Import of slaves into the U.S. was criminalized. Some
slaves were imported illegally up to 1860. Estimates of their number range from
250,000 to 1 million.
1816: The African Methodist Episcopal Church is
founded in Philadelphia PA.
1818: The Chief Justice in Upper Canada (now Ontario)
ruled that a runaway slave should not be returned to the U.S.
1821: Benjamin Lunday, a Quaker from Ohio, started an
anti-slavery newspaper "The Genius of Universal Emancipation."
1821: The African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church is
founded.
1825: Fanny Wright (1795-1852), organized Nashoba. This was a training
school to help slaves handle liberation from slavery. She was a religious free-thinker
(secularist), and was the first American woman to personally speak out against
slavery in public.
1829's: Congregationalists, Quakers, Mennonites, Methodists and
Unitarians organized the "underground railway" to help slaves escape northward
towards Canada and southward into Spanish held territories.2
1829: David Walker, a free-born African-American published the first major
U.S. anti-slavery publication: "The David Walker's Appeal in Four Articles
Together With A Preamble, To The Coloured Citizens of The World, But In Particular, And
Very Expressly, To Those of The United States of America." Walker died in 1830.
Some suspect that a group of slave-owning Southern governors took a contract out on his
life. He criticized Christian denominations for their relative silence about slavery and
racism; he condemned those among the white clergy who supported slavery.3
1830: The Plantation Mission Movement began. Methodist
chapels were constructed on many plantations.
1831: Nat Turner, a Baptist slave pastor, led a major
sustained slave revolt in Virginia. He was inspired by the messages of
the Old Testament prophets and their calls for justice.
"...the notion that slavery was God's will gained
momentum after the Nat Turner slave rebellion of 1831. In hundreds of
pamphlets, written from 1836 to 1866, Southern slaveholders were
provided a host of religious reasons to justify the social caste system
they had created."4
1833: Over 1,000 regional, state and city groups joined together to
found the American Anti-Slavery Society.
1833: The British Parliament passed a law which
quickly phased out slavery in Britain and its colonies, including
Canada. Slave trading
by other countries was gradually snuffed out during the following 3 decades, by a series
of treaties and the capture of over 1,000 slave ships by the British.
1833: The Anti-Slavery Convention of 1833 was held.
One of the vice-presidents was Dr. Lord, who later reversed his
stance. He became an "advocate of slavery as a divine
institution, and denounced woe upon the abolitionists for interfering
with the will and purpose of the Creator." 4
1838: The Presbyterian church split over slavery.
1839: Pope Gregory XVI wrote in Supremo Apostolatus that he
admonishes and adjures "in the Lord all believers in Christ, of whatsoever
condition, that no one hereafter may dare unjustly to molest Indians, Negroes, or other
men of this sort;...or to reduce them to slavery..." The operative word is
unjustly.
The Pope did not condemn slavery if the slaves had been captured
justly -- that is, they were either criminals or prisoners of
war.
Roman Catholic Bishops in the Southern U.S. determined that this prohibition did not apply
to slavery in the U.S. To their credit, various other popes did order or otherwise influence the
emancipation of slaves that they considered to be unjustly enslaved.
1840: By this time, the United States had developed an obvious
north/south split over slavery. The cotton-based economy of the Southern states depended largely on the
low cost labor provided by the slave population. In the industrialized North, slavery had
become only marginally economic. This split was reflected in the views of the various
Christian denominations with respect to abolition. Many Christians in the southern states
saw abolition as a massive threat to their culture and economy. They did not view slavery
as a sin; their leaders were able to quote many Biblical passages in support of slavery.
Many Christians in the northern states had gradually built up a revulsion towards the
"peculiar institution." In opposition to slavery, they frequently quoted Jesus'
statements about treating others with respect and love.
1841 to 1844: The Baptist movement in the U.S. had maintained a
strained peace by carefully avoiding discussion of the topic. The American Baptist
Foreign Mission Board took neither a pro nor anti-slavery position. An American
Baptist Anti-Slavery Convention in 1840 brought the issue into the open.
Southern delegates to the 1841 Triennial Convention of the Board "protested
the abolitionist agitation and argued that, while slavery was a calamity and a great evil,
it was not a sin according to the Bible." 5The Board
later denied a request by the Alabama Convention that slave owners be eligible to
become missionaries. In a test case, the Georgia Baptist nominated a slave owner as a
missionary and asked asked the Home Missions Society to approve their choice. No
decision was made. Finally, a Baptist Free Mission Society was formed; "it
refused 'tainted' Southern money." The Southern members withdrew and formed the Southern
Baptist Convention, which eventually grew to become the largest Protestant
denomination in the U.S.
1843: Clergy and laity of the Methodist Episcopal Churchleft to form the Wesleyan Methodist Church in America. The split was
caused primarily by the slavery issue. The church had reneged on an earlier decision to
forbid members to own slaves. Church teaching and practices were two additional points of
friction. The Wesleyan Methodist Church continues today as the Wesleyan
Church.
1843: "In 1843, 1,200 Methodist ministers owned
1,500 slaves, and 25,000 members owned 208,000 slaves...the Methodist
Church as a whole remained silent and neutral on the issue of
slavery."5
1844: The General Conference of the Methodist Episcopal Church
split into two conferences because of tensions over slavery and the power of bishops in
the denomination. The two General Conferences, the Methodist Episcopal Church (North)
and Methodist Episcopal church, South remained separate until a merger in 1939
created the Methodist Church. The latter became the present United Methodist
Church as a result of additional mergers. 7
1851: J.F. Brennan published "Bible defense of
slavery." He claimed that Cain's parents were Eve and the
serpent. 8
1860: Ministers and laity of the Methodist Episcopal Church's
Genesee Conference in western New York state were expelled from the church for
insubordination. They left to form the Free Methodist Church of North America.
They split over a variety of factors, including theological disagreements, the perceived
worldliness of the original church, and slavery. Their leader "...Roberts and
most of his followers were radical abolitionists in the years immediately prior to the
Civil War, at a time when many within the Methodist Episcopal church were hesitant in
their condemnation of the practice of slavery." The denomination continues today
in the U.S., Canada and in countries around the world. 9
1861: The Presbyterians were able to remain united in spite of tensions
created by the slavery issue. Shortly after the Civil War began, the Southern presbyteries
of the United Presbyterian Church in the United States of America withdrew and
organized the Presbyterian Church in the Confederate States (later renamed the Presbyterian
Church in the United States). The split was healed in 1983 with the merger of these
two bodies and the creation of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.).
1861-1865: The Civil War (a.k.a. the war between
the states) was fought.
1863: President Abraham Lincoln issued the Emancipation
Proclamation on JAN-1. This is believed by many to have freed the
slaves. Actually, it did not. Former slaves in the Northern states had
already been freed; slaves in the south were part of the Confederacy,
and thus immune to Union proclamations. Author Joel Panzer
concluded that Catholic bishops in the U.S. at this time taught that
buying and selling slaves was immoral, but merely owning a slave was
acceptable to the church. Panzer considers this to be a misinterpretation
of Papal teaching. 11
1865: The 13thAmendment to the Constitution of the United
States ended slavery.
1866: The Holy Office of the Vatican issued a
statement in support of slavery. The document stated that
"Slavery itself...is not at all contrary to the natural and
divine law...The purchaser [of the slave] should carefully examine
whether the slave who is put up for sale has been justly or unjustly
deprived of his liberty, and that the vendor should do nothing which
might endanger the life, virtue, or Catholic faith of the slave."
Some commentators suggest that the statement was triggered by the passage
of the 13th Amendment in the U.S. Others claim that the document
referred only to a "particular situation in Africa to have slaves under
certain conditions," and not necessarily to the situation in the U.S.
12
1873:Pope Pius IX was concerned about the "wreched
Ethopians in Central Africa." He prayed that "Almighty God may at
length remove the curse of Cham [Ham] from their hearts."
God's curse on Ham was that the Canaanite people would be forever enslaved. Some
theologians had long used this Biblical passage to justify enslavement of Africans.
1888: Brazil became the last country in the Western hemisphere to
abolish slavery. The Roman Catholic Church reversed its stance "from the
affirmation to the condemnation of slavery." 10 Pope
Leo XIII sent a letter to the Brazilian Bishops saying that
"from the beginning,
almost nothing was more venerated in the Catholic Church...that the fact that she looked
to see a slavery eased and abolished...Many of our predecessors...made every effort to
ensure that the institution of slavery should be abolished where it existed and that its
roots should not revive where it had been destroyed."
This statement does not
agree with the historical record. Previous church documents clearly stated that slavery
was quite permissible, as long as the slave was a non-Christian and the slave's captors
were fighting in a just war.
1917: The Roman Catholic church's Canon Law was expanded to declare a
that "selling a human being into slavery or for any other evil purpose"
is a crime.
1965: The Vatican II document "Pastoral Constitution on the
Church in the Modern World" stated:
"Whatever violates the integrity of
the human person, such as mutilation, torture...whatever insults human dignity, such
as...slavery, prostitution and selling of women and children...all these things and others
like them are infamous...Human institutions...should be bulwarks against any kind of
political or social slavery and guardians of basic rights under any kind of government."
The rejection of slavery as a profoundly immoral practice became gradually
accepted by Christians throughout Western countries. This had a serious negative
effect on the Christian faith. By rejecting the validity of the pro-slavery passages in
the Bible, they were forced to accept that the Bible could not be considered a totally
reliable guide on civil and moral topics. This created a serious disillusionment among 19th
century Christians. The authority of the Bible became suspect for the first
time. In the intervening years, the slavery passages
became almost entirely ignored. Some translations of the Bible softened the verses by
replacing "slave" with "servant." However, the Bible could no longer
be fully accepted as a guide for public and personal morality, equally applicable for all
societies and all eras. Some Biblical moral truths became widely accepted as true only for
a specific group or for a specific time in history.
Slavery continues in two Muslim countries, although its
existence is denied by their governments.
Human slavery was used widely by the Nazi regime in Germany during World War II.
The present German government has paid about 8 billion dollars in financial
compensation to former slaves. Also during that war, Japan became what was
probably the largest pimping operation in the world by
enslaving one to four hundred thousand "comfort women" to function
as sex slaves for the Japanese armed forces. The Japanese government has never
offered financial compensation to the women that they abused.
Near-slavery has now replaced slavery as a source of major concern.
M. Fiedler & L. Rabben, Ed., "Rome has spoken...A guide to forgotten Papal
statements and how they have changed through the centuries," Crossroad, (1998)
Page 81.
Joel Panzer, "The Popes and Slavery," Alba House, (1996) Read
reviews or order this book safely from Amazon.com online book store Some
reviewers at Amazon.com commented that this book is a useful source of Papal
statements on slavery. However, the author is accused of bending the truth.
Highlighting one example, a reviewer wrote: "Whereas he mentions the work
of the Catholic priest, Bartolomeo de las Casas, in ending the enslavement of
the indigenous peoples by the Spanish colonists, Fr. Panzer is completely
silent about De las Casas' suggestion that Africans be used as slaves instead."
Leonard Kennedy, " 'The Popes and Slavery' — book review," Catholic
Educator's Resource Center," at:
http://catholiceducation.org/