"The passion of the Christ"
The movie's contents
Topics covered in this essay:
The actors and director:
Mel Gibson (b. 1958) is an Academy Award winning actor and director. He
co-wrote, directed, produced, and financed the "The Passion of the Christ."
The main actors are:
James Caviezel, who starred in The Thin Red Line, was cast as
Yeshua of Nazareth (Jesus Christ). His was a difficult role. He was
allegedly struck by lightning during the filming. He suffered hypothermia
and a dislocated sholder. Two of the whip strokes missed his protective gear
and hit his body with incredibly painful results.
||Monica Belluci plays Mary Magdalene.
||Maia Morgenstern plays Mary, the mother of Yeshua.
The film was shot in Italy. Great efforts were made to replicate the
language, clothing, architecture, decor, etc. of Judea in the first century
CE. Early versions of the movie were extensively previewed
by many religious
groups before it was released to thousands of movie theatres across North
America on 2004-FEB-25.
It is worth noting that the name of the film is "The Passion of The Christ,"
not "The Passion of Christ." "Christ" is being referred to in its
original meaning of "Messiah." It is not Yeshuah's (Jesus') last name, as
many people believe.
Much of the public believes that the movie was based on the Gospel of John. The film's official web site states that the movie
"was adapted from a composite account of The Passion assembled from the four Biblical gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke and John.
" 1 However, the Gospels were extensively supplemented by a number of other sources, including two Roman
The "diaries of St. Anne Catherine Emmerich (1774-1824) as collected
in the book, 'The Dolorous Passion of Our Lord Jesus Christ'." 2 She was an Augustinian nun who lived in Germany. Many
information sources incorrectly state that she was the author of the book.
In reality, it was Brentano, a
famous German author and poet, who assembled descriptions of her visions into book form.
3 One posting on a mailing list to which we subscribe
wrote that when they read this book, they thought that they were reading Mel
Gibson's screen play.
"The Mystical City of God" by St. Mary of Agreda (1602-1665).
The dialogue in the four gospels could probably fill less than a half-hour
of film. A great deal of non-biblical material was added in order to flesh out
the movie to its full length of 126 minutes. Whether this additional material
was similar to the real events and dialog in first century CE
Judea is a matter of debate.
This essay continues below.
How closely do the actors resemble the historical characters?
The actor who
plays the role of Yeshua, Jim Caviezel, resembles the common perception of
Jesus: a tall male with a pale face; Caucasian and not Middle Eastern in
appearance. Yeshua probably looked very different
-- with a broad peasant's face, dark olive skin, short curly hair and a
prominent nose. His height would have been on the order of 5' 1"; he would have
weighed about 110 pounds. Other actors look similarly pale and tall compared to
the historical characters that they were playing. The movie has greatly departed
from the historical reality, presumably in order to meet the public's
About Satan and the ugly baby:
Rosalinda Celentano played the role of Satan in the movie. She appears as an
androgynous being, both in the introductory scenes in the Garden of
Gethsemane and during the scenes when Jesus is being flogged. Neither
appearance is mentioned in the Bible.
After receiving many queries from readers, Christianity Today magazine
asked Mel Gibson why he had shown Satan in this manner, and what the
significance of the ugly baby was. Gibson replied: "
"I believe the Devil is real, but I don't believe he shows up too
often with horns and smoke and a forked tail. The devil is smarter than
that. Evil is alluring, attractive. It looks almost normal, almost good?but
"That's what I tried to do with the Devil in the film. The actor's face
is symmetric, beautiful in a certain sense, but not completely. For example,
we shaved her eyebrows. Then we shot her almost in slow motion so you don't
see her blink?that's not normal. We dubbed in a man's voice in Gethsemane
even though the actor is a woman ? That's what evil is about, taking
something that's good and twisting it a little bit."
Commenting on the ugly baby, Gibson said:
"Again, it's evil distorting what's good. What is more tender and
beautiful than a mother and a child? So the Devil takes that and distorts it
just a little bit. Instead of a normal mother and child you have an
androgynous figure holding a 40-year-old 'baby' with hair on his back. It is
weird, it is shocking, it's almost too much -- just like turning Jesus over to
continue scourging him on his chest is shocking and almost too much, which
is the exact moment when this appearance of the Devil and the baby takes
There were four languages spoken and written in Judea and the Galilee during the first
||Aramaic was the language used by Yeshua and other Jews. This appears frequently in the movie's sound track. Nobody
speaks that language today. A language consultant was hired to attempt to
reconstruct the spoken language as it may have sounded in ancient times. One
dialect of Aramaic, called Syriac, is still spoken today by some Jews and
Christians in the Middle East. There are an estimated 250,000 Chaldean and
Assyrian Christians in the United States whose previous generations
frequently spoke in Syriac. However the use of the language is gradually
dying out. With the massive exodus of Christians from the Middle East in
recent decades, emigrants often learn the language of their adopted country
and no longer speak Syriac.
"Street Latin" was the language used by the Roman occupying army. It also appears
in the movie.
Greek was very widely used in ancient Judea and Galilee. It was the one language
that many people held in common and facilitated people speaking to others
outside their group. It would probably have been the language of choice for
communications between the Romans and Jews. However, it was not heard in the
movie. The film's official web site states that "Greek, which was
commonly spoken among the intellectuals of the period, was not quite as
relevant to the story." 1
||Hebrew was the original spoken and written language of the ancient
Israelites. It was an almost dead language by the first century CE. It
rarely appears in the movie.
English subtitles are
shown. However, one of the most inflammatory sentences in the Bible, was spoken
in Aramaic without subtitles.
The sentence was one of the the two biblical verses which have probably been
responsible for more deaths of innocent people than any other passages.
Exodus 22:18, in some translations, calls for the execution of
all "witches," although a more accurate translation of the original
Hebrew would call for the extermination of "women who use spoken curses
to injure or kill other people." This partially justified the
extermination of tens of thousands of persons considered to be witches and
other heretics during the late Middle Ages and early Renaissance.
Matthew 27:25 states: "Then answered all the people, and said,
His blood be on us, and on our children." (KJV). In this passage, the
author of the Gospel of Matthew has the entire Jewish mob in front of
Procurator Pontius Pilate's palace demanding Yeshua's crucifixion, and
accepting full responsibility for the act. Further, they are recorded as
accepting that their children would inherit their guilt. Historically,
Christian churches had taught that the blame
extended beyond the mob and their children to all Jews who were in Jerusalem
at the time, and to all Jews in the world who were alive at the time, and to
all of their descendents down through the centuries. This was one of the
main theological beliefs used by the Church to justify centuries of
oppression, mass murders and genocides of Jews.
It was only in the 1960s that the Roman Catholic Church finally repudiated
these teachings. On 1965-OCT-28, at the Second Vatican Council, the Vatican
issued "Nostra Aetate," a "Declaration on the Relation of the
Church to non-Christian Religions." 1
It says in part: "...neither
all Jews indiscriminately at that time, nor all Jews today, can be charged
with the crimes committed during his passion." After receiving criticism
from some religious leaders who previewed an early version of the movie,
Gibson decided to delete the English subtitles for this passage.
However, the words are still heard in Aramaic.
The movie is "R" rated because of the level of violence, blood
The movie was released to theatres in the U.S. and Canada on 2004-MAR-11.
According to Forbes magazine:
The Passion cost about $30 million to produce and $15 million to
Most U.S. movies don't even break even with the revenue from North
American theatre ticket sales. They rely on subsequent DVD/video sales, and
international box office sales. However, The Passion had already
grossed $125.2 million during its first five days in movie theatres.
||Forbes estimates that the eventual gross revenue from theatre showings
could reach $350 million in the U.S. and Canada, and another $300 million
will probably receive about 40 to 50% of the gross revenue.
Icon will probably also receive between 9 and 15% of the
wholesale value of merchandise associated with The Passion. This
includes mugs, and nail pendants.
The DVD and video version of the movie should go on sale during the
summer of 2004. 5
According to BoxOfficeMojo.com, the total
U.S. and Canadian gross by 2004-MAR-11 was $232 million. In addition, the
overseas gross from Australia, Greece and New Zealand brought in an additional
$8.2 million. 6
By Easter Sunday, 2004-APR-11, the total U.S. and
Canadian gross had reached $354.8 million. It became the 8th largest grossing
movie of all times in North America, having just passed The Lord of the
Rings: The Two Towers. 11
By Labor Day, 2004-SEP-6, the film earned $370
million in the U.S. and Canada and over $600 million worldwide. It had become
the highest-grossing R-rated movie of all time, and the 8th highest grossing
film of all time in the U.S.
On 2004-AUG-31, the film was released for general
sale on video at a retail cost of $29.98 on DVD and $24.95 on VHS. However, most
outlets seem to be offering discounts.
What happened to some people who watched the movie:
TV station KAYE of Wichita KS comments that: "The movie has been
criticized for its graphic portrayal of Jesus' death. Religious leaders around
the country and here in Wichita say people need to be prepared for the graphic
brutality...religious and medical officials stress this film is not for the
Barna Research, a conservative Christian group which specializes in polling
public opinion on religion, conducted a study during the last week of 2004-MAY.
1,618 adults were sampled. margin of error is 3.9%.They found that:
31% of American adults had seen the movie. This compared with 57% for "Finding
Nemo," and 42% for "Bruce Almighty."
||59% of those who had seen one or more movies during the previous two
years that had caused them to reflect on their faith listed The Passion of
the Christ as one of the movies.
For the viewers of the movie:
||67% found the movie excellent; 23% good; 7% average and 2% below average
||89% of Evangelical Christian rated the movie as excellent. So did 78% of
other Protestants and 68% of Roman Catholics.
||53% were born-again Christians. This is higher than their incidence
||4% were Atheists or Agnostics. This is much lower than their incidence
||16% felt that the movie affected their religious beliefs.
||18% felt that the movie affected their religious practices
||10% changed both their religious beliefs and practices in response to
||Less than 0.5% were motivated to be more active in sharing their faith
||Less than 0.1% made a profession of faith or accepted Jesus as their
Lord and Savior as a result of viewing the film.
Some individual responses to the movie:
||Melissa and Sean Davidson in Statesboro GA started to argue with each other
as they left the movie. They debated whether God the Father in the Holy Trinity
is human or symbolic. Melissa allegedly pulled out a pair of scissors, stabbed
Sean's hand, and ripped off his shirt. Sean allegedly injured Melissa's arm and
face. Both reported each other to the police; both were charged with battery.
A woman, known as Peggy Scott and Peggy Law, 56 or
57, of Wichita KS had a heart attack while viewing the crucifixion scene of the
movie. She was pronounced dead at a local hospital. 8,9
||Pastor Jose Geraldo Soares, 43, a Presbyterian
minister from Minas Gerais in Brazil died of a sudden heart attack during the
movie. He was watching the movie with his wife, their two children, and members
of their congregation. 10
Various people went to the
police to confess past criminal acts. One admitted that he had murdered his a
girlfriend. James Anderson from Palm Beach Gardens, FL allegedly robbed a bank more than
two years previously. "he was stirred deeply after watching The Passion of
the Christ and felt compelled to come clean." He surrendered to police and
urged the detective to see the movie too. 9
||A married woman in her 40's
in New Britain, CT, drove her car into a pond at city park in order to baptize
||A man in his early 20's in Somerset County, VT, built a cross in his living
room and nailed one of his hands in place. He then realized that he had a
problem: he was unable to nail his other hand to the board. He called 911 for
assistance. It is not clear whether he wanted the emergency response crew to
nail his other hand in place, or to release his original hand.
Retail sales of the movie:
The movie was released for retail sales on 2004-AUG-31. Nominal prices were
$29.98 U.S. for the DVD version and $24.96 for VHS. Many stores were offering
significant discounts. Unlike most DVDs, there are "no frills, no bonus
coverage, no director's commentary, no behind-the-scenes stories or interviews
-- virtually no DVD extras whatsoever, other than the option of Spanish
subtitles." 12 A special
version including some of these features may be made available at a later date.
Shortly before the film was released, Religion News Service (RNS)
interviewed Rabbi Marvin Hier, founder of the Simon Wiesenthal Center and the
Museum of Tolerance. He said: "If you're asking me if we have changed our
positions, absolutely not." Hier said he still feels the film depicts Jews "in
a very negative manner." Abraham Foxman, national director of the
Anti-Defamation League (ADL) who lodged such strong protests earlier in 2004
before its theater release, told the RNS there's nothing more to say on the
topic because "DVD is not the event the film was."
20th Century Fox reported that, during its first week of sales, nearly 9
million copies were sold: some in DVD format, and others in VHS. The Toronto
Star reported this with the heading: "Jesus, that's a whole lot of DVDs."
A companion book, web site and soundtrack:
National Religious Broadcasters honor Mel Gibson:
At its 2005-MAR annual convention, the National Religious Broadcasters
honored Mel Gibson with its Board of Directors Award for his work on "The
Passion of the Christ" movie. The Award "honors a Christian who
demonstrates integrity, displays creativity and makes a significant impact on
society." The NRB is an association of religious broadcasters which
limits its membership to Fundamentalist and other Evangelical Christians.
"The Film / Background Info," at:
Anne Emmerich, "The Dolorous Passion of Our Lord Jesus Christ," Tan
Books, (Reprinted 1994).
reviews or order this book safely from Amazon.com online book store
Anne Emmerich, "The Dolorous Passion of Our Lord Jesus Christ,"
" 'The Passion': What's Not in the Bible? Because scripture is silent
on certain details, Mel Gibson drew from extrabiblical sources to craft his
'Passion'." Beliefnet, at:
Penelope Patsuris, "What Mel's Passion Will Earn Him," Forbes
magazine, 2004-MAR-3, at:
"The Passion of the Christ," at:
Up With the Ugly Baby? Everyone's asking
about the Passion scene
where Satan is carrying a hideous infant," Christianity Today,
- "Woman Collapses During Showing of 'The Passion
Of The Christ'," at:
- Carl Limbacher, " 'The Passion' Prompts Robber
to Surrender, Couple to Batter," Newsmax, 2004-MAR-18. Posted at:
- "Minister dies watching Jesus movie,"
Reuters, 2004-MAR-23, at:
- David Germain, "Audiences want Easter with
Passion," Associated Press, 2004-APR-11.
- Mark Moring, "Mel Gibson's film now on video,"
Christianity Today, 2004-AUG-31, at:
- "New Survey Examines the Impact of Gibson?s
'Passion' Movie," The Barna Group, 2004-JUL-10, at:
Copyright ? 2004 and 2005 by Ontario Consultants on Religious
Originally written: 2004-FEB-24
Latest update: 2005-MAR-04
Author: B.A. Robinson