Religious Tolerance logo

Menu:
Reproductive and therapeutic cloning

horizontal rule

Quotations on reproductive cloning (creating duplicate humans):

bullet Conservative position: "...scientists who envision medical breakthroughs using stem cells from human embryos are now moving on to human cloning -- breeding people for the purpose of harvesting their tissues and organs from their bodies, then disposing of them." 1

bullet Liberal position: "Human cloning allows man to fashion his own essential nature and turn chance into choice. For cloning's advocates, this is an opportunity to remake mankind in an image of health, prosperity, and nobility; it is the ultimate expression of man's unlimited potential." 2

horizontal rule

Quotations on therapeutic cloning (creating human organs for transplanting):

bullet Conservative position: "Cloning, even so-called therapeutic or experimental cloning, creates a new life without a father, and reduces a mother to the provider of an almost emptied egg. Nonetheless, it is a new human life and the determination to destroy it and limit its use to scientific research for therapeutic ends compound further the moral issues rather than protect mankind. As such, cloning embryonic human life under any circumstance crosses an ethical line, takes an irrevocable step, from which science can never turn back." 3
 
bullet Liberal position: "Therapeutic cloning will in time allow scientists to create organs that are a perfect match for those in need of a transplant. The cloned organ would be based on the recipientís genetic material and would not require the use of debilitating immunosuppressive therapies. There would also be no chance of rejection, which is fatal. Therapeutic cloning represents the ideal in organ transplantation, as it would provide an unlimited source of organs to anyone who needs them. The need for these organs is dire." 4

horizontal rule

Sponsored link

horizontal rule

Overview:

It is unfortunate that the term "cloning" refers to three very different procedures with three very different goals. It is also unfortunate that the first thought many people have when they hear the term is of horror movies which have showed the creation of human monsters or of armies of superhuman soldiers with subhuman brains. The reality of cloning is very different.

The three different types of "cloning" are:

bullet Embryo cloning: This is a medical technique which produces monozygotic (identical) twins or triplets. It duplicates the process that nature uses to produce twins or triplets. One or more cells are removed from a fertilized embryo and encouraged to develop into one or more duplicate embryos. Twins or triplets are thus formed, with identical DNA. This has been done for many years on various species of animals; only very limited experimentation has been done on humans.

bullet Adult DNA cloning (a.k.a.  reproductive cloning) This technique which is intended to produce a duplicate of an existing animal. It has been used to clone a sheep and other mammals. The DNA from an ovum is removed and replaced with the DNA from a cell removed from an adult animal. Then, the fertilized ovum, now called a pre-embryo, is implanted in a womb and allowed to develop into a new animal. This may or may not have been tried on humans. It is specifically forbidden by law in many countries. There are rumors that Dr. Severino Aninori has successfully initiated a pregnancy through reproductive cloning. It has the potential of producing a twin of an existing person. Based on previous animal studies, it also has the potential of producing severe genetic defects. For the latter reason alone, many medical ethicists consider it to be a profoundly immoral procedure when done on humans.

bullet Therapeutic cloning (a.k.a. biomedical cloning): This is a procedure whose initial stages are identical to adult DNA cloning. However, the stem cells are removed from the pre-embryo with the intent of producing tissue or a whole organ for transplant back into the person  who supplied the DNA. The pre-embryo dies in the process.  The goal of therapeutic cloning is to produce a healthy copy of a sick person's tissue or organ for transplant. This technique would be vastly superior to relying on organ transplants from other people. The supply would be unlimited, so there would be no waiting lists. The tissue or organ would have the sick person's original DNA; the patient would not have to take immunosuppressant drugs for the rest of their life, as is now required after transplants. There would not be any danger of organ rejection.

There are major ethical concerns about all three types of cloning, when applied to humans.

horizontal rule

Sponsored link:

horizontal rule

Topics covered in this section:

bulletEmbryo cloning (a.k.a. artificial twinning) Part 1  Part 2

bullet Reproductive cloning (to produce an exact twin of an existing person or other animal) This is essentially a dead issue. The risks involved make reproductive cloning profoundly unethical.

bullet How it is done, history, its morality

bullet News items during the years....
bullet 1997 to 2000 incl.
bullet 2001
bullet 2002
bullet 2003 to now

bullet Therapeutic cloning (to produce an organ that matches that of an existing person)

bullet How is it done; possible benefits

bullet Ethics, Public opinion

bullet One person's belief: Human personhood is in the blood

bullet Amniotic stem cells discovered

bullet U.S. legislation

bullet News items
bullet Up to the end of  2001
bullet 2002
bullet 2003
bullet 2004
bullet 2005
bullet 2006 & 2007

bullet Comments on cloning by individuals, political groups, & religious authorities
 
bullet Missouri amendment, 2006-NOV: allows therapeutic cloning & bans reproductive cloning
 

Related essay on this website:

bullet Stem cell research

horizontal rule

A molecular biology resource for researchers:

  • Addgene is a non-profit plasmid repository dedicated to helping scientists around the world share high-quality plasmids. See: https://www.addgene.org/

horizontal rule

Sponsored link:

horizontal rule

You can buy these books safely from Amazon.com's online bookstore:

horizontal rule

References:

  1. Anon, "Still Work to Do," Focus on the Family Magazine, 2004-JAN, Page 21
  2. Patrick Stephens, "Cloning: Towards a new conception of humanity," The Reproductive Cloning Network, at: http://www.reproductivecloning.net/
  3. Daniel Reilly, "Statement on human cloning," The Diocese of Worcester, (Roman Catholic), 2001-NOV-26, at: http://www.worcesterdiocese.org/
  4. Justin Durivage, "Therapeutic cloning raises new questions concerning morality," The Student File, 2001-DEC-07, at: http://www.tsl.pomona.edu/

horizontal rule

Copyright ©1997 to 2013 by Ontario Consultants on Religious Tolerance
Originally published: 1997-AUG-5

Last updated 2013-MAR-05
Author: Bruce A Robinson

line.gif (538 bytes)

Sponsored links


horizontal rule

Go to the previous page, or go to the "Hot religious topics" menu, or choose:

Custom Search

Go to home page  We would really appreciate your help

E-mail us about errors, etc.  Purchase a CD of this web site

FreeFind search, lists of new essays...  Having problems printing our essays?


Twitter link

Facebook icon

GooglePage Translator:

This page translator works on Firefox,
Opera, Chrome, and Safari browsers only

After translating, click on the "show
original" button at the top of this
page to restore page to English.

privacy policy