About this site
About us
Our beliefs
Your first visit?
Contact us
External links
Good books
Visitor essays
Our forum
New essays
Other site features
Buy a CD
Vital notes
World religions
BUDDHISM
 
CHRISTIANITY
Who is a Christian?
Shared beliefs
Handle change
Bible topics
Bible inerrancy
Bible harmony
Interpret Bible
Persons
Beliefs, creeds
Da Vinci code
Revelation, 666
Denominations
 
HINDUISM
ISLAM
JUDAISM
WICCA / WITCHCRAFT
Other religions
Cults and NRMs
Comparing religions
Non-theistic...
Atheism
Agnosticism
Humanism
Other
About all religions
Important topics
Basic information
Gods & Goddesses
Handle change
Doubt/security
Quotes
Movies
Confusing terms
Glossary
World's end
One true religion?
Seasonal topics
Science v. Religion
More info.
Spiritual/ethics
Spirituality
Morality/ethics
Absolute truth
Peace/conflict
Attaining peace
Religious tolerance
Religious hatred
Religious conflict
Religious violence
"Hot" topics
Very hot topics
Ten commandm'ts
Abortion
Assisted suicide
Cloning
Death penalty
Environment
Equal rights - gays & bi's
Gay marriage
Nudism
Origins of the species
Sex & gender
Sin
Spanking kids
Stem cells
Women-rights
Other topics
Laws and news
Religious laws
Religious news

Web site logo

Cremation vs. burial: Jewish & Christian beliefs

horizontal rule

Sponsored link.

horizontal rule

What is Cremation?:

The word cremation comes from the Latin word cremo which means "to burn" - particularly the burning of the dead.

Cremation generally involves the application of high temperature, typically between 1400 and 2100 Degrees Fahrenheit (760 to 1150 Deg. C), to a wooden box or casket which contains a dead body. The body and container are almost completely consumed; the cremated remains consist of bone fragments and particles, which usually weigh from 4 to 8 pounds (1.8 to 3.6 kg). They are then finely ground into granule form. The entire process takes 3 to 5 hours. Although the attendants attempt to remove all of the remains, a small portion will be left inside the cremation chamber, and subsequently mingled with the next body to be cremated.

During 1999-JUL, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency conducted 10 test cremations to determine the optimum temperature for cremation, in order to minimize smoke, dust and gas emissions. They expected to release formal guidelines in the year 2000.

Most bodies that are not cremated are buried in a casket where they gradually decompose over time.

horizontal rule

History of Cremation:

Most archaeologists believe that cremation was invented during the stone age, about 3000 BCE. 1 It was most likely first used in Europe or the Near East. It became the most common method of disposing of bodies by 800 BCE in Greece, and 600 BCE in Rome. However, other societies had other methods:
bulletin ancient Israel, sepulchers (tombs or vaults) were used for burial; cremation was shunned. The body was exposed to the air of the tomb and simply decomposed.
bulletthe early Christian church also rejected cremation, partly because of its association with Pagan societies of Greece and Rome. Christians buried their dead in graves or in catacombs (underground vaults).
bulletin ancient Egypt, bodies were embalmed.
bulletin ancient China, they were buried.

When Christianity became the official religion of the Roman Empire, and the followers of other religions were exiled or exterminated, burial became the only method of disposing of bodies throughout Europe.

An Italian, Professor Brunetti, developed the first modern cremation chamber in the 1870's. This triggered a movement towards cremation in Europe and North America, which has continued to the present day. In 1886, the Roman Catholic Church officially banned cremations. Church members as recently as World War II were excommunicated for arranging them. The Eastern Orthodox ecumenical patriarch of Constantinople stated in 1961 that "There is no formal Orthodox rule against cremation, but there is a heavy weight of custom and sentiment in favor of Christian burial" 2

There are currently about 1,100 crematories and 470,915 cremations per year in North America.

horizontal rule

What Does The Bible Say About Cremation?:

The Hebrew Scriptures (Old Testament) has a few references to the disposal by burning in fire. Some verses describe executions by Philistines or Babylonians. Burning of bodies and objects in ancient Israel were mostly reserved for idols, criminals or enemies:
bulletGenesis 38:24: Judah initially ordered his pregnant daughter-in-law to be burned to death because she was guilty of prostitution. This action would have caused the death of the woman and her twin fetuses.
bulletExodus 32:20: Moses destroyed the golden calf by burning it.
bulletLeviticus 20:14: If a man marries both a woman and her mother, then all three "must be burned in the fire" (NIV). The passage is ambiguous: it is not known whether they would be burned alive, or would be stoned to death first, and their bodies burned
bulletLeviticus 21:9: If the daughter of a priest becomes a prostitute, then she "must be burned in the fire." (NIV)
bulletNumbers 16:35: God exterminated Korah and 250 Israelite men with fire because they opposed Moses.
bulletDeuteronomy 7:25: God commanded that the idols of Pagan Gods be destroyed with fire.
bulletJoshua 7:15-25: After Joshua and his army exterminated the men, women and innocent children of Jericho, a few soldiers disobeyed God's command and looted the city. As punishment for the theft, and to pay for Israel's disgrace, God ordered the thieves to be burned. They were stoned to death; their bodies were burned and buried in what was called the Valley of Achor.
bulletJudges 15:6: The Philistines burned Samson's wife and father-in-law to death.
bullet1 Samuel 31:11-13: Earlier in the chapter, Saul had been wounded and asked for assisted suicide from his armor-bearer. The latter refused, so Saul committed suicide himself. The Philistines impaled Saul's body and those of his sons and left them on public display. The people of Jabesh Gilead retrieved the bodies, burned them and later buried the remaining bones in Gilead. There have been a number theories raised to account for this unusual treatment to a hero:
bulletburning might have a local custom in Gilead.
bulletthe people of Gilead may have been worried that the Philistines might dig up the bodies and further desecrate them.
bulletburning might have been necessary because their bodies may have partly decomposed.
bulletthe Hebrew word translated as "burnt" might actually mean "annointed"; thus, the bodies might not have been burned after all.
bullet2 Kings 10:26: Jehu demolished a temple consecrated to the God Baal and burned its sacred stone.
bulletJeremiah 29:22: This verse contains a curse which refers to the time that the Babylonians burned Zedekiah and Ahab by fire.
bulletAmos 2:1: God proclaimed a death curse on Moab because he had reduced the bones of the king of Edom to lime through burning.

The Christian Scriptures (New Testament) contain few references to burning of bodies or objects:
bulletActs 19:19: Sorcerers who were converted to Christianity brought their scrolls out to be burned.
bulletRevelation 20:15: The fate of those whose names were not written in the Book of Life is to be thrown into the lake of fire.

horizontal rule

Sponsored link:

horizontal rule

What Does The Bible Say About Burial? (Continued):

The burial of many important Biblical figures is described in the Bible: 2
bulletGenesis 25:8-10: Abraham
bulletGenesis 23:1-4: Sarah
bulletGenesis 35:19-20: Rachel
bulletGenesis 35:29: Isaac,
bulletGenesis 49:33 and 50:1-13: Jacob
bulletGenesis 50:26: Joseph (The Israelites went to great effort to bury his body in the Promised Land; they retained it for over 300 years in Egypt and after the Exodus during 40 years of wanderings before burying it.)
bulletDeuteronomy 34:6: Moses (God selected a burial site at a secret location in Moab for Moses.)
bulletJoshua 24:29-30: Joshua
bulletJoshua 24:33: Eleazar
bullet1 Samuel 25:1: Samuel
bullet1 Kings 2:10: David
bulletMatthew 14:10-12: John the Baptist
bulletActs 5:5-10: Ananias and Sapphira
bulletActs 8:2: Stephen

To be not given a proper burial was considered to be a great tragedy and dishonor.
bullet1 Kings 13:22: A prophet disobeyed God by eating a meal in a forbidden location. God laid a curse on him: that his body would not be buried in the tomb of his fathers. Shortly after, the prophet was attacked by a lion and his remains left on a road.
bulletJeremiah 16:6: God laid a horrible curse on the Israelites: that many would die of diseases, will not be mourned and would be "like refuse lying on the ground" (NIV). Their bodies will be consumed by animals and birds.
bulletJeremiah 22:19: God laid a similar curse on Jehoiakim because of his pride and disobedience. Jeremiah said that he would be given the burial of a donkey: to be dragged away and thrown outside the city gates
bulletCrucifixion: Of the countless number of tombs in Palestine from the era of Roman occupation which have been excavated, only one skeleton has been found which bears the marks of a crucifixion. That is because after a Roman execution, the lifeless body would be typically discarded in an open pit where it would be devoured by wild dogs. To be forbidden a traditional burial added greatly to the horror of this method of execution.

horizontal rule

Is it Wrong for Christians to Choose Cremation?:

Some factors which favor cremation:
bulletit can be more economical, because a simple container can be used in place of an expensive casket.
bulletthere is no cost associated with the purchase and perpetual care of a grave site, or tombstone.
bulletit allows scattering of the remains in a place of significance to the deceased.
bulletsome people would rather have their body disposed of quickly by heat rather than allow it to decay in a grave.

Some factors which favor burial:
bulletGod selected burial at Moses' death (Deuteronomy 34:6).
bulletMost of the reference to burning of a body in the Bible are instances of:
bulletpunishment for criminal acts,
bulletpunishment for improper behavior,
bulletkillings by Pagans, or
bulletdestruction of idols and evil material.
bulletSt. Paul appears to favor burial. In 1 Corinthians 15:35-44, he discusses how God will raise the decomposed body of a believer. The symbolism used is that of planting a seed and having new life rise from the decaying seed.
bulletThe Christian church has advocated burial since its inception. They reserved burning for Witches and other heretics. They exterminated hundreds of thousands of them, mainly during the 15th to 18th centuries.
bulletCremation can be an aid to murderers. Once a body has been cremated, it cannot be exhumed and analyzed for poisons.

Various Christian groups have taken a variety of positions on cremation:

bulletThe People's Gospel Hour condemns the practice.
bulletThe Roman Catholic Church used to condemn the practice. In fact, the only German Catholics excommunicated during World War II were not prison guards at extermination camps or other mass murderers; they were individuals who favored cremation. 6
bulletRBC Ministries suggests a cautious approach. 7
bulletMost Christian groups take a neutral stance.
bullet"Cremation is completely banned by traditional Jews. Orthodox and Conservative practice would allow it only in a time of plague. Otherwise, interment in a Jewish cemetery is mandated." These beliefs are reinforced by recent memories of the millions of Jews who were cremated in the death camps of Nazi Germany. However, some rabbis in the Jewish Reform movement support cremation if it is the wish of the deceased.  8,9

horizontal rule

Cremation Statistics:

As North American society becomes progressively more secular, it is expected that cremation will gain in favor, and become the normal method of disposing of bodies. A second factor is ecological sensitivity: some people do not want their remains to utilize badly needed land.

The number of cremations in North America has increased dramatically in recent years: from 5% in 1962 to 20% in 1992. 3 As of 1996, about 21% of Americans and 36% of Canadians are cremated at death. Percentages (2) vary from 75% in BC, to 61% in HI, 50% in WA,... 7% in LA, 4% in GA, 3% in MS and 1% in Newfoundland. 4 The high number in British Columbia is partly caused by the large transient population in the province, and the presence of many Hindus and Sikhs who are almost always cremated. Cremation is expected to be the preferred method of disposing of bodies in Canada about 2015 CE. 5

The following chart shows data from the Cremation Association of North America (CANA): 4

United States Data
Year Number of cremations % of all deaths
1998 553,000 24.1%
1999 598,721 25.0%
2000 estimated figure 604,828 25.5%
2010 projected figure 1,552,800 40%

 

Canadian Data
Year Number of cremations % of all deaths
1998 213,004 42.4%
1999 221,650 Not available
2000 estimated figure Not available 42.7%
2010 projected figure 1,552,800 47.4%

There are over 30,000 funeral homes in the U.S. and Canada offering cremation services. There are also hundreds of cremation or memorial societies. The Internet Cremation Society 6 has links to many cremation service providers.

horizontal rule

References used in the above essay:

The following information sources were used to prepare and update the above essay. The hyperlinks are not necessarily still active today.

  1. The history of cremation is described at: http://www.cremationinfo.com/
  2. Philip Jackman, "Cremation now a hot option," Globe and Mail, 1998-SEP-9
  3. Cover story, USA Today, 1995-DEC-5
  4. Cremation statistics are at: http://www.cremation.org/
  5. Philip Jackman, "Cremation now a hot option," Globe and Mail, 1998-SEP-9
  6. James W. Fraser, "Cremation: Is it Christian?", Loizeaux Brothers, Inc., (1965); Pamphlet available from The Peoples Gospel Hour, PO Box 1660, Halifax NS, Canada, B3J 3A1
  7. "Is it wrong for Christians to arrange for their bodies to be cremated," RBC Ministries at: http://www.gospelcom.net/
  8. "Body and soul: Why is cremation forbidden," Being Jewish website, at: http://www.beingjewish.com/
  9. Rabbi Gary A. Huber, "Is cremation allowed in Reform Judaism? What is your policy regarding this funeral practice?" at: http://www.qn.net

horizontal rule

 Internet information sources:

  1. Cremation Specialists at: http://www.cremation.com/index.asp
  2. Internet Cremation Society at: https://cremation.org/
  3. Perfect Memorials supply quality wood, bronze, glass, metal and marble cremation urns for both people and pets. Their selections also include keepsakes, 14K jewelry, infant and other memorial products. See: http://www.perfectmemorials.com/
  4. Everlife Memorials supply cremation urns & jewelry. Delivery within the 48 contiguous states is free. See: http://www.everlifememorials.com/
  5. Perfect Memorials

horizontal rule

Copyright 1997 to 2007 by Ontario Consultants on Religious Tolerance
Latest update: 2007-AUG-05
Author: B.A. Robinson

line.gif (538 bytes)

horizontal rule

Go to the previous page, or return to "HOT" religious topics, or choose:

Google
Web ReligiousTolerance.org

Go to home page  We would really appreciate your help

E-mail us about errors, etc.  Purchase a CD of this web site

FreeFind search, lists of new essays...  Having problems printing our essays?

  >