Polls have consistently shown that American adults support equal employment protection
for persons of all sexual orientations:
1995: A poll by Newsweek magazine taken among actual voters
showed that 84% supported equal rights for gays and lesbians in the workplace.
1996-MAY: A Newsweek poll showed that 84% of American adults supported
equal protections in employment for gays and lesbians.
1996-JUN: An American public opinion poll was taken in by ICR Survey
Research Group of Media, PA. Results are correct within 3 percentage points, 19 times
out of 20.
Same-sex marriage:
Overall results: 57% opposed; 30% in favor
Females responded: 49% opposed
Persons under 35: 47% opposed; 47% in favor
Equal job opportunities: 10% opposed; 85% in favor (vs. 16 to 76% in 1992)
Exclude gays totally from the military: 15% in favor of a ban
Allow openly gay or lesbian persons into the military 37% opposed; 40% in favor
1996-JUN: A poll by the Associated Press showed that 85% of adults are
in favor of federal legislation to give equal protection in employment to gays and
lesbians.
1996-NOV: Greenberg Research Inc. conducted a national survey of
1,007 voters at election time on 1996-NOV-5 to 8. They found that:
Among Christians generally, 70% believe that gays and lesbians should be protected from
discrimination in the workplace; 23% do not.
Among fundamentalist and other evangelical Christians, 60% are in favor while 34% do not.
The poll's margin of error is ± 3.1 percent, 19 times out of 20.
1997-APR: A public opinion poll was conducted during 1997-APR 8 to 10
by the Tarrance Group and Lake Sosin Snell & Associates. They asked
American adults whether they supported a Federal law to "prevent job
discrimination against gays and lesbians." Results showed that ENDA has 68%
support nationally, 77% in the Northeast, 71% in the Midwest, 68% in the West, and 62% in
the South. It is supported by 79% of Democrats, 69% of independents, and 59% of
Republicans. Only about 15% of adults are "strongly opposed."
1997-OCT: Oliver Thomas of the National Council of Churches
and Herbert Valentine of the Presbyterian Church (USA) were scheduledto
talk in support of ENDA before the Senate Labor and Human Resources Committee. A
procedural move prevented them from being heard. Will Dodson, director of public policy
for the Southern Baptist Convention's Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission
said that he:
"walked away from the hearing both sad and angry...I walked away angry because there were actually church
leaders who were there to support the bill. As Christians, our response to this issue
should be to love the sinner and hate the sin. It is infuriating to hear church leaders
suggest that we are showing love for the sinner by accepting his sinful behavior.
Christians ought to be helping them to escape a sinful, harmful lifestyle. I can
understand how those without Christ would defend their lifestyle. However, it is
inexcusable that Christians would defend lifestyles which are contrary to Scripture."
Dodson appears to have been misinformed. Thomas and Valentine were not at
the Senate committee to promote, accept or defend homosexuals. They were
trying to give them job security.
1998-JUL-31: A public opinion poll with a margin of error of 4% was
conducted by the Princeton Survey Research Associates for Newsweek
magazine on 1998-JUL-30 & 31. It found that 83% of the general population felt that
gays and lesbians deserve equal rights in obtaining jobs. Legislators will ignore these
poll data at their peril.
Many large companies
have gone on record as supporting ENDA.
Winnie Stachelberg, legislative director of the Human Rights Campaign said
"Employment protections [for lesbian and gay workers] have really
emerged as a mainstream, bipartisan issue."
In 1996-SEP, Matt Coles, director of the Lesbian and Gay Rights
Project of the American Civil Liberties Union" stated:
"We are on the verge of passing legislation that will finally
ensure fairness for all American workers, regardless of sexual
orientation...While we have a lot of work ahead of us in the coming days,
the momentum is clearly on our side."
As one might expect, much of the opposition comes from conservative
Christianity. One example
is:
Kristi S. Hamrick, Director of Communications for The Family Research Council
(FRC)
issued a news release on 1997-APR-24 titled "Pro-family America will Fight the
ENDA Agenda of Putting Sex Into the Workplace". She made a number of following
points.:
A USA Weekend survey of 1997-APR-18 shows that most Americans do not support
ENDA, by a margin of 55% to 45% [These survey results deviate greatly from
all other
surveys. The wording of the questions asked in that poll may have been
biased.]
ENDA will introduce a pro-gay bias in hiring. [since the words "gay,"
"lesbian," "homosexual," "heterosexual," and
"bisexual" do not appear in the bill, there does not appear to be any
way in which individuals of one sexual
orientation could be favored by the bill.]
ENDA will extend civil rights coverage from characteristics that cannot be changed, such
as skin color, to sexual behaviors. [The implication is that
sexual orientation can be
changed. Professional mental health associations agree that it is a fixed
characteristic in all or essentially all adults. Also the FRC overlooks
the fact that religion, a chosen activity, is already a protected class]
ENDA would prevent employers from disciplining any employee for any sexual act while on
the job. [This is an interesting interpretation of the bill. ENDA prohibits discrimination
on the basis of sexual orientation; it would not prohibit discipline for persons of any
sexual orientation found fornicating on the job.]
ENDA would give homosexuals special rights [Persons of all sexual orientations are given
equal rights; neither bisexuals, gays, heterosexuals or lesbians would be given special
rights.]
ENDA would lead to quotas for gays and lesbians [Quotas are specifically prohibited by
ENDA.]
The Capitol Hill Prayer Alert athttp://www.prayeralert.org/ asks
that Christians pray against the ENDA bill. Their web site starts with an apparent wish
that all gays and lesbians die: "Although they know God's righteous decree that
those who do such things deserve death, they not only continue to do these very things but
also approve of those who practice them" (Romans 1:32). Some points raised in
their essay:
ENDA is a "pro-homosexual measure"
ENDA would be the first federal legislation which would "...extend special
favor to people based on their chosen behavior..." [The bill gives equal
protection to persons of all sexual orientations. Mental health
professionals generally agree that adults do not choose their
orientation, and cannot change it.]
The bill will give protection to those involved in "...polygamy, incest,
pedophilia, beastiality [sic] and other forms of sexual perversion." [It will
not; it is limited to sexual orientation only.]
Christian employers' "freedoms of religion, speech and association will be
violently stripped away" by the bill. [They will not. Employers can continue to
hate homosexuality or heterosexuality; they can hate homosexuals and heterosexuals.
The bill only states that employers would be unable to discriminate against them.
In the same way existing laws allow
employers to hate persons of different races, genders, nationalities, etc. But they are
unable to discriminate against them.]
They ask readers to pray "That God will CRUSH ENDA, whatever form it may
take."
1997-JUN: Rep. Christopher Says (R-CT) and other sponsors brought forth a slightly modified
form of the ENDA bill in early 1997-JUN. Changes include:
The bill prohibits the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from collecting data on
workers' sexual orientation or requiring quotas or preferential treatment of gays,
lesbians, bisexuals or heterosexuals.
Religious organizations would be exempt from the legislation.
Says commented that the bill:
"is based on a fundamental principle most of us
share: Americans should be judged at work because of their performance at work...It would
guarantee that gay men and lesbians have the same opportunity the rest of us now take for
granted: to get and keep a job based on the merits of the work we do and not on some
characteristic we have that is entirely irrelevant to the value of our work."
Another sponsor, Rep. Barney Frank, (D-Mass), said "This bill simply says that you
will be judged in the work place on the merits. Period...There is absolutely nothing to be
said against it."
Robert Knight, director of cultural studies for The Family Research Council,
commented:
"It will outlaw Christianity, Orthodox Judaism and every belief
that says homosexuality is wrong...It will expand government power and give
a massive weapon to gay activist lawyers to harass employers all over
America."
The FRC is one of the
main conservative Christian organizations in the area of social policy.
Kerry Lobel, executive director of the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force
stated on 1997-JUN-10:
"The message of ENDA is clear and straightforward.
Discrimination is wrong. We look forward to the day when gay, lesbian, bisexual and
transgendered people no longer have to fear the loss of their jobs on the basis of their
sexual orientation. When that day comes, our society will have taken another step forward
in assuring justice and equality for all of its citizens."
On 1997-JUN, ENDA has the support of 34 senators and 146 members of the
House. Although it is almost certain to die for the next few times that it is presented to
Congress, many political observers feel that its eventual passage is inevitable.
Republican leaders have vowed to not bring the bill to the house floor for a vote. There
is every indication that the general public is giving increasing support to the concept of
equal rights for persons of all sexual orientations.
1999-JUN:
President Clinton asked congress to pass ENDA. 4
The AFL-CIO strongly urged congress to pass ENDA. 5
Bills were introduced into both the House and Senate on JUN-24:
H.R. 2355, was sponsored by Reps. Christopher Shays (R-CT) and
Barney Frank (D-MA). S 1276 was sponsored by Senators James Jeffords (R-VT), Ted Kennedy (D-MA), and Joseph Lieberman (D-CT).
None made it into law.
2002-MAR: Senator Ted Kennedy, (D-MA) has re-introduced an
Employment Non-Discrimination Act (ENDA). It is bill S1284. The
Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee held a
meeting to review the bill in late 2002-FEB.
2002-MAY: S1284, was approved by the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee
on MAY-1. Senate Majority Leader, Tom Daschle, has promised to introduce
the bill to the Senate before the end of session this fall.
"With 43
Senate co-sponsors, and poll numbers that suggest that a strong majority
of Americans support equal opportunity in the workplace, ENDA is
expected to pass the Senate, giving the GLBT community another rare
congressional victory."
However, Republicans in the House prevented ENDA and a bill to expand
hate crime legislation to include women and homosexuals from proceeding.
References used in the above essay:
The following information sources were used to prepare and update the above
essay. The hyperlinks are not necessarily still active today.
Associated Press, "Shays Brings Back Legislation to Ban Anti-Gay
Discrimination", 1997-JUN-10 (PM)
J.E. Rigdon, "Overcoming a Deep-Rooted Reluctance, More Firms Advertise to Gay
Community,", Wall Street Journal, 1991-JUL-18, Page 1B
Tom Strode, "Church leaders endorse ENDA; SBC rep decries their defense"
at: http://www.erlc.com/