Toby Talbot of Earthlink wrote an article on 2005-JAN-08 that looked
back on the impacts that civil unions had had in Vermont since they became
available 4½ years earlier, on 2000-JUL-01. 1 Some observations:
There was initially a serious division among Vermonters on the topic
of civil unions. Many who were opposed posted "Take Back Vermont"
signs. Some of those in favor used "Vermont: Keep it Civil"
stickers. However, most Vermonters now accept civil unions as a new part of
their culture.
The Democrats, who were strong supporters of civil unions, "have
returned to their place of political dominance in the Statehouse."
There are now five openly gay men in the state's General Assembly.
This is an increase from one when civil unions first became available.
Exit polls in the 2004-FALL elections showed that:
36% of voters prefer that same-sex couples should be able to
enter into civil unions only.
40% would support full marriage rights for same-sex couples.
21% said there should be no legal recognition of same-sex
relationships; loving committed same-sex couples should be treated as roommates
under law.
3% were undecided or did not respond.
Marty Rouse, campaign director of Mass Equality -- a group working
to preserve same-sex marriage in Massachusetts said:
"Vermont led
with civil unions but how quickly civil union has become the moderate,
conservative position. We're now talking full equality and marriage is
full equality. Hopefully, one day, Vermont will get to full equality."
Rev. Craig Bensen, a pastor and lobbyist who actively opposed civil
unions, said:
"I anticipate that if there were an attempt to do
Massachusetts-style marriage that the public would be heavily favored to
maintain the status quo."
He was unsuccessful in running for the
state Senate as a Republican.
Steve Kimbell, a lawyer and lobbyist who actively promoted civil
unions said:
"I think there's still a small slice of the population
who, for their own personal, religious reasons, can't abide anything to
do with gay and lesbian people. [However,] for a growing majority, the
fact that life has gone on as usual means it's OK. More and more people
are understanding who gay and lesbian people are around them. You can't
be mean to people you know. These are people in the fabric of everyday
life." 1
Former state representative Tom Little (R) is chairing the Commission on
Family Recognition and Protection. They are studying whether marriage in
Vermont should be expanded to include loving, committed same-sex couples. Other
members of the bipartisan commission include former Gov. Phil Hoff, Johnson
State College president Barbara Murphy, former legislators, a quarry owner and
an Episcopal priest. They held their first meeting on 2007-AUG-23 and dealt with
administrative issues, including the organization of public meetings.
Opponents of same-sex marriage have allegedly decided to boycott the public
meetings:
Stephen Cable, president of Vermont Renewal, said
"As a result of their actions and refusal to address the issues we
have raised, we are asking Vermonters to boycott the hearings and pay no
attention to the [commission's] report." 2
Craig Benson, founder of Take It to the People, promotes a
plebiscite on same-sex marriage. He said:
"This political farce is a waste of taxpayer's time, attention and
tax money. This is the left having a dialogue with the far left while
everyone else is left out." 2
Other comments:
Vermont House Speaker Gaye Symington (D) said:
"I think for many Vermonters the question has been when, not so much
as whether, we would eventually recognize same-sex union through
marriage. I think many people saw civil unions as a first step." 3
Governor Jim Douglas (R) said:.
"I really think it's important for the Legislature to work with me to
focus on what is important to everybody in Vermont and that's the cost
of living in Vermont." 3
Senate President Pro Tempore Peter Shumlin (D) now supports marriage
equality even though he voted against the year 2000 civil union bill. He
said:
"I think now most Vermonters would acknowledge it hasn't impacted
their families in any way, shape or form." 3
The Commission's report is expected to be issued
during 2008-APR. No action would be taken on the report until 2009, in order to
avoid making same-sex marriage an election issue.