Status of same-sex marriages (SSM) and civil unions:
As of 2006-MAR, same-sex marriages are only available in
the Netherlands, Belgium,
Massachusetts, Spain, and
Canada. Some jurisdictions limit SSM to residents
only. Their legislators or courts have simply re-written their
marriage laws so that loving, committed couples of all sexual orientations can marry.
However, the states of Vermont,
CaliforniaConnecticut,
New Zealand, the UK, and other countries allow gays
and lesbians to enter into civil unions or domestic partnerships. In the U.S., these couples
receive all of the rights, privileges, and obligations that the state gives to
married couples, but are denied over 1,000 federal
benefits.
Gallup Organization poll data 1996 to 2003:
The Gallup Organization has been polling the public since 1996
about
same-sex marriages and civil unions. For most
polls, they asked the question: "Suppose that on election day this year
you could vote on key issues as well as candidates. Please tell me whether
you would vote for or against each one of the following propositions.
Would you vote...For or against a law that would allow homosexual couples
to legally form civil unions, giving them some of the legal rights of
married couples."
In 2001 they asked a slightly different question: "Would you favor or oppose a law that would allow
homosexual couples to legally form civil unions, giving them some of the
legal rights of married couples?" Their 2003 survey involved 1,005 randomly
selected adults. The margin of error was ±3
percentage points. 1 Results were:
Date
Favor unions
Oppose unions
No opinion
1996-APR
28%
67%
5%
2000-OCT
42
54
4
2001-MAY
44
52
4
2002-FEB
41
53
6
2002-APR
45
46
9
2002-MAY
46
51
3
2003-MAY
49
49
2
By early 2003-MAY, the Gallup results country was equally divided between those favoring and those opposing civil
unions for gays and lesbians. This is a legislators' nightmare; no matter what
they do -- or if they do nothing -- they will have massive numbers of voters
angry at them. The momentum clearly was in the direction
of a clear majority of American adults favoring unions in the near future. Further,
the percentage of adults with no
opinion has steadily dropped.
Results of a similar poll by the Washington Post were
announced on 2003-AUG-14. Three unusual events had occurred between the
May and August polls:
The
Episcopal Church, USA confirmed the election of a gay bishop who
is in a committed relationship, and allowed their congregations to
decide whether to bless same-sex relationships.
Perhaps because of these developments, there was a precipitous drop
of 12% in support for civil unions.
They asked: "Do you strongly favor, favor, oppose, or strongly oppose
allowing gay and lesbian couples to enter into legal agreements with each other
that would give them many of the same rights as married couples?"
The question was similar to that asked by the Gallup Organization above,
except that "legal agreements" replaced "civil unions" and "many of the same
rights" replaced "some of the legal rights."
Date
Favor unions
Oppose unions
No opinion
2003-OCT
45%
47%
8%
2004-MAR
49
44
7
2004-JUL
49
43
8
2004-AUG
48
45
7
2005-JUL
53
40
7
Equal numbers of American adults appear to have supported and opposed civil
unions during early 2004. There has been a trend towards supporting civil unions
ever since. Still, the current level of support would probably be insufficient
to assure passage of a proposition or plebiscite. That is because:
A statistically designed survey among randomly selected adults gives a
reasonably correct estimate of the percentages who are for and against civil
unions, with a predictable accuracy.
A plebiscite or proposition only represents the wishes of those who are
sufficiently motivated to get out and vote. It is well known that, on
average, those who oppose benefits to same-sex couples are far more
passionate about restricting rights than those who favor benefits have
enthusiasm about granting rights.
References used:
The following information sources were used to prepare and update the above
essay. The hyperlinks are not necessarily still active today.
"Six out of 10 Americans Say Homosexual Relations Should Be
Recognized as Legal
But Americans are evenly divided on issue of legal civil unions between
homosexuals giving them the legal rights of married couples," The
Gallup Organization, 2003-MAY-15, at:
http://www.gallup.com/poll/releases/
*
"New Poll: Majority of Americans are Defenders of Marriage,"
Family Research Council, Washington Update, 2003-AUG-14.
Richard Mornin & Alan Cooperman, "Poll shows strong disapproval of religious sanctioning of same-sex relationships,"
Washington Post, 2003-AUG-14, at:
http://www.ajc.com/