TRUTH, DAMN LIES AND EXECUTION
An essay donated by Dave Jarvis
Three hundred years ago, courts of justice could be blinded by
superstition. In those dark times, people in positions of power could
snuff out the light from any candle of hope that the condemned still
held for life. Innumerable falsely accused victims were burned at the
stake, ignited by the flames of flourishing injustice, and fanned by the
falsehoods spoke by their peers. Sadly, no joyous sunrise would come to
end their tortured nights of captivity.
But three hundred years later, courts remain hoodwinked by dishonesty.
Three hundred years later, lives are still tossed to the proverbial pit
of fire. Three hundred years later, people in positions of power
demonstrate that they are impossibly all-knowing, all-seeing, and
all-hearing by summarily judging the actions of others and then doling
out executions with omnipotent strength. And so I share with you today a
reiteration that acts can be neither omniscient nor omnipotent, that we
all have faults, and by extension so do our governments and judicial
In a sense, capital punishment is like writing a cheque to purchase the
life of a criminal. A payment, some argue, that is cheaper than
supporting lifelong imprisonment. Yet the laws of Australia, Canada, the
United States of America, and numerous others guarantee the "unalienable
Rights" of Life and Liberty. Our past actions liberated slaves and all
but abolished slavery. Our present actions show that we believe the
authority to limit the life of a human being belongs to no one. But cold
heartedly, these representative cheques continue to be cashed at Banks
of Justice, even though Banks of Life and Liberty would return them
marked "insufficient funds"!
We must refuse to endorse Banks of Justice that continue to honour such
cheques. We refuse to believe that money can indemnify human lives,
regardless of the crimes in question. These deplorable bank drafts must
be nullified to redeem our courts of justice and our humanity.
Every moment that our voices remain silent widens the gap between being
human and being humane. There is an urgency that cannot, must not, be
ignored. Every hour of apathy lends credence to legalized vengeance. Now
is the time to speak out for those lost voices smothered behind iron.
Now is the time to turn our backs on barbaric States. Now is the time to
tell the people in power that killing is wrong. Now is the time to teach
compassion to all of our children.
Lives are lost forever by ignoring the fierce urgency of Now. The dark
winter veil of cold-blooded murder will not be lifted until the
springtime infusion of life is guaranteed throughout our societies. And
those who believe that tomorrow will be just another day will have a
rude awakening if the executions continue. There will be neither rest
nor tranquility in the world until unconditional life is granted to all
its citizens. The snowstorm of revolution will not end until the clear
dawn of humble justice emerges.
And to the people united on the peaceful threshold of merciful justice:
Do not embark in wrongful deeds. Life cannot be sanctioned by vengeful
actions or riotous demonstrations. No, the Right to Life will not be
chartered by outbursts of physical violence. Our actions must embody
this monumental goal; we must segregate villainous force from moral force.
When light from our morality is used to judge the shadows cast by
criminals, we must appraise ourselves and our laws by the same rays of
ethics. To do otherwise places governments and judicial systems beyond
the reach of mediated introspection, beyond the grasp of justice itself.
By this beam of self-inspection, when a death sentence is dispatched we
lift the offender to the moral equality of societal norms, and find
ourselves standing deep inside the shadows of criminals.
We shall not walk in those shadows.
We will walk without the specter of hypocrisy to haunt our footfalls.
And as we walk, our steps bring us closer to a golden era that waits ahead.
We cannot turn back.
There are those who oppose the progression toward leniency. They raise
statistics like a stoic hammer, driving the belief that executing
murderers will reduce homicides. However, this interpretation does not a
nail in the coffin make. Numbers are tools to add weight to debates;
debates that must be continually cross-examined for applicability and
accountability. Yet statistics are also the claw to the hammer's head,
pulling out deterrence arguments by suggesting that legitimizing murder
through the death penalty actually raises the rate of homicides!
So we will not be satisfied by statistics. We can never be satisfied as
long as the guiltless are slaughtered. We cannot be satisfied when
fallible humans are the judge and the jury to deadly trials. We can
never be satisfied while the Press pilots our opinions with
sensationalized stigma. No, no, we are not satisfied and we will not be
satisfied until tolerance towers like the tallest of trees and
forgiveness flowers like an endless forest.
Let us be mindful that forgetfulness is not a bedfellow of forgiveness.
To forget that many death row inmates committed terrible crimes would
let befall a grave injustice. By the same token, to overlook that the
dead can only be exonerated posthumously defiles the memory of innocent
victims. Instead of incapacitation, let criminals atone for their crimes
with positive contributions to society. Instead of martyrs, make them
educators. Instead of miscreants, fashion them material makers. Instead
of misfits, mold them as missionaries. Instead of being slain for
malevolence, give them the chance to change.
Even though we face the turmoil of retribution, we can see the tenets of
redemption. Within these tenets, I, too, have a dream.
I dream of a day when no human will have the right to revoke the life
I dream of a day when miscarriage of justice does not result in fresh
flowers to a solitary grave, but in the freedom of an unjustly accused
I dream of a day when even the ghosts of Salem Massachusetts, whose
deaths were inconceivably shackled to "spectral evidence", and whose
memories still mock modern justice, may finally find peace.
I dream of a people who understand that no heated crime warrants a cold
resolution by death; that death is unjustly everlasting when pit against
both fleeting and permanent transgressions; and that humane disciplines
can meet the needs of society while being a fair reproach for felonies.
I have a dream today!
I dream of a world where we can judge our justice systems as though they
were individuals: not by the color of their skin, but by the content of
their character. Where at the highest courts of international law we
find that justice is morally, ethically, and logically consistent across
I have a dream today!
I dream of a world in which Mercy opens the Door of Knowledge to reveal
that the real truth in any situation can never be known entirely. A
world in which we are keenly aware that the whirlwind of motives,
emotions, psyche, and actions behind a trial cannot be judged and
punished with absolute conviction. A world that has cast off the
rattling chains of death to embrace the foundations of life.
I dream of a world without injustice buried within injustice. A world
where the poverty line does not foreshadow a flat line. A world where the
accused wealthy and the convicted poor face their fates with equal
outcomes and equal opportunities. A world where the concept of just
justice is not an ironic fairytale, but a practical reality.
This is our dream, a dream inspired by an extraordinary man.
In the spirit of Dr Martin Luther King Jr., a man who made an enormous
march for liberty, these words strive to be an extension of his ideas, a
continuation to his ideals. But this time the walk is for life. And
along the road to the global abolishment of capital punishment sits a
world that is one small step closer to unity. It is only through this
journey will our collective conscience truly be free at last.
Originally posted: 2005-NOV-14
Latest update: 2005-NOV-14
Author: Dave Jarvis