Religious Tolerance logo

RITUAL ABUSE CASES IN MUENSTER, GERMANY

horizontal rule

Sponsored link.

horizontal rule

Rainer Moellers, a male nursery teacher at a Montessori nursery in Muenster, was fired because of allegations of ritual abuse. The concerns originated with a conversation between a child, his mother and a friend of the mother who is a social worker and member of a local feminist group. The allegation centered around the taking of the child's temperature; it was quickly cleared up. But, after a series of talks to parents by the feminist group, additional allegations surfaced. Parents received a checklist of warning signs of sexual abuse. In 1992, Moellers was charged with abusing 62 children at 2 nurseries. Charges included:

bullet Inserting toothbrushes and toothpaste in their anus
bullet Inserting spoons in their vagina
bullet Group oral and penetrative sex simultaneously
bullet Penetration by other devices: toy cars, soap, pencils
bullet Sticking pins, needles, nails and a penknife into genitals
bullet Smearing jam, nutella, toothpaste, excrement and sperm on genitals and licking it off
bullet Ejaculation, defecation and urination on the children on nursery carpets.
bullet Painting genitals with water paints
bullet Forcing children to eat excrement out of toilet bowls
bullet Pornography and videos
bullet Burial in coffins
bullet Threats of harm by dangerous animals, magicians, death threats
bullet Journeys to a white house (later discovered to be a theater refreshment stand), where the children witnessed women being sacrificed.

As in essentially all ritual abuse cases, medical examinations revealed two factors:

bullet there was no evidence to confirm any of the charges
bullet if some of the abuse had happened, physical evidence would have been present

A key personality in the case was Psychiatrist Tilman Fürniß (Fuerniss) of the local university, the University of Muenster. He wrote The Multiprofessional handbook of Child Sexual Abuse (1991), and had been part of the original child sexual abuse team at Great Ormond St. Hospital in London England. This team had imported many of the techniques and assumptions of child abuse questioning from the US, including the use of anatomically correct dolls and hypothetical questioning. These dolls have since been shown to have limited use in cases where sexual abuse was known to have happened. But they can generate entirely false accusations when used on a "fishing expedition" with young children (1, P. 161-186). Hypothetical questioning has also been discredited. Prof. Fürniß has lectured extensively about the prevalence of pedophile rings operating in institutions, and his writing have influenced many child care workers and therapists.

Two Fürniß-trained trauma therapists worked with the children and parents; he ran some sessions himself. Statement Validity Analysis (SVA) by various psychologists was divided:
bullet some said that the more extreme allegations were fantasy, an extension of genuine abuse.
bullet Others felt no abuse had occurred at all and that the psychological symptoms in the children were caused by the investigation.

Applicable forms of SVA became a point of contention in this and other European cases. Some forms appear to be highly accurate, while others tend simply to confirm the prejudices of the investigators. Psychological profiles of the accused did not support his being a likely abuser. None of the staff had observed any usual behavior by Moellers. Other people were named as alleged perpetrators but charges were withheld and finally abandoned as the controversy over the Moellers case intensified.

A major influence was a long article in Der Spiegel in 1993-JUN which critically drew attention to the role of Prof. Fuerniss and the similarity between this case and the McMartin and Kelly Michaelscases in the US. The article mentioned the similarity with a case in Bjeugn, a small Norwegian village. This too was heavily influenced by the writings of Prof. Fürniß and included allegations made by children against four men and three women, complete with the same ritual abuse stories as mentioned in the Montessori case.

Mr. Moellers was eventually tried; he was acquitted on all counts in early 1995.

horizontal rule

Sponsored link:

horizontal rule

A second case of alleged mass ritual abuse of children surfaced in Worms, Germany. Apparently another therapist trained by Professor Fürniß was involved in bringing this case forward. The alleged perpetrators were found not-guilty in 1997-JUN.

horizontal rule

Reference

  1. S.J. Ceci & M. Bruck, "Jeopardy in the Courtroom: A Scientific Analysis of Children's Testimony", American Psychological Association, Washington DC (1995)

horizontal rule

Return to the OCRT home page; or the "Not so Spiritual" page; or the "Ritual Abuse Cases" menu

Search