HOW WIDESPREAD IS SATANIC/SADISTIC
RITUAL ABUSE? -- PART 2
Sponsored link.
INDICATORS THAT SADISTIC/SATANIC RITUAL ABUSE DOES NOT EXIST (Cont'd)
12. BURIAL OF CORPSES
There have been countless instances in which a SRA survivor has taken police
investigators to the exact location where she saw bodies being buried after human
sacrifices. The police search the area and sometimes bring in heavy earth moving machinery
to help. At most, they will recover a few bones from animals who have died of natural
causes. No human bodies have ever been unearthed.
SRA promoters will counter the lack of corpses with the assertion that the Satanists
came back later, secretly dug up the bodies and buried them elsewhere. They would have
done this in order to ruin the credibility of any member who turned against the
"cult". But this theory does not hold water. One has to dig a pit in order to
bury a body. And, even when the pit is filled in, it is still detectable - often for tens
of thousands of years. The change in soil consistency between firm, compacted dirt and
loose dirt is easily detected. Bacteria will grow quickly in loose earth and change the
soil color significantly. So, even if the bodies are removed, the filled-in pits remain in
place.
13. ACCIDENTAL DISCOVERIES BY POLICE OR FIRE FIGHTERS
One would expect that a building somewhere where SRA was practiced would eventually
catch on fire. The fire fighters would then find evidence (pens for holding victims, blood
soaked altar, etc.). Similarly, a SRA location would sooner or later be entered by the
police in a drug raid, and evidence would be found. No such cases are known.
14. MAJOR GOVERNMENT STUDIES
Investigations have been completed by four governments: the state of Virginia (1991),
and the governments of Great Britain (1994), the Netherlands (1994) and the United States
(1994). 1All have shown that SRA does not exist at any significant level in their
jurisdictions.
If SRA existed in any level, one would expect at least one government study somewhere
would have found evidence of it.
15. GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION OF SRA
Belief about widespread SRA and a strong SRA industry exists only in countries, where
belief of the reality of the Christian devil as an evil, active, person is widespread.
These include the Australia, US, Canada, England, and New Zealand. With the possible exception of the Netherlands,
"Satanic panics" have not been triggered in countries in which belief in the
Satan is rare. They have fizzled in the rest of Europe.
If SRA exists internationally, one would expect it to be present in all nominally
Christian countries.
16. WHERE DO THE HUMAN SACRIFICES COME FROM?
There are about 25,000 known homicides in the US each year. SRA promoters typically
claim that an additional 50,000 people, mostly infants, are killed in human sacrifices by
Satanic (and similar) groups. Since the kidnapping of even one child can trigger a
nation-wide search, it is difficult to comprehend how 50,000 infants and
children could disappear and not be
noticed.
SRA promoters often answer this argument with the concept of breeding camps. These are
concentration camps in which thousands of women are kept prisoner, and continually kept
pregnant. Their new-born babies are then transported across the US and Canada for
sacrifice. One such camp near Cornwall ON is supposed to imprison 2,500 women. This would
pose serious problems of concealment. Such a camp would be many times larger than the
largest of Canadian penitentiaries, and would require a total staff of about 1000. Any of
the staff could become instantly very rich by simply telling their story to the National
Inquirer; it would be the story of the decade. Such a prison would be impossible to hide
for long.
SRA would require a plentiful supply of babies for sacrifice. No such supply exists.
17. GENDER IMBALANCE AMONG SRA PERPETRATORS
The SRA industry promotes the concept that most abuse and programming is done by
parents of survivors; i.e. by both mother and father. The abuse, torture and human
sacrifices by Satanists (or other groups) is viewed as both:
intra-family: involving the victim, her mother, her father and perhaps grand parents
inter-family: involving a Satanic grotto composed of many mothers, fathers and their
children.
The perpetrators are thus evenly divided between men and women.
However, the vast majority of sexual predators of children are male. Convicted
pedophiles are almost all male; few females are ever involved. Thus the SRA industry's
belief concerning the gender makeup of the perpetrators does not agree with decades of
studies of sexual abusers.
18. INTER-GENERATIONAL CONTINUITY OF ABUSE
The SRA industry promotes the concept that abuse is inter-generational in nature. That
is that grandparents abuse their children who then grow up, become parents, and abuse
their children, etc. Their belief is that SRA has existed for many decades, perhaps for
centuries, and that one of the reasons for the abuse is to perpetuate the Satanic movement
to include future generations.
At the same time, they promote the concept that survivors of SRA (adults with memories
of having been ritually abused as children) are not child abusers themselves. They believe
that children of survivors are not at risk.
These two concepts are mutually exclusive.
19, THE LACK OF CONTINUOUSLY PRESENT MEMORIES
Adults who report memories of childhood incest fall into two groups:
those who have recovered memories during therapy - memories which were not present
before therapy
those who have always had the memories - continuously from childhood to the present time
Many professionals in the memory research and mental health fields suspect that many of
the first group's memories are false. However, there are (sadly) plenty of people in the
latter group who prove the existence of childhood incest, our most serious social problem.
Adults who report memories of childhood SRA fall into the same two groups. But only
three people are known to be the second group: Michelle Smith, Laurie Stratford and
"Elaine". Michelle and Laurie wrote books about their abuse which have been
shown to be frauds. Rebecca Brown wrote a book about Elaine which has also shown to be a
hoax.
If SRA really existed, one would expect that there would be thousands or tens of
thousands of adults whose memories of childhood SRA were continuously with them - just
like horrific memories of the Holocaust, Cambodian genocides, etc. have always been
present in their victims. There seem to be no "always present" memories of SRA.
20. THE NATURE OF RECOVERED MEMORIES
About 17% of adults who report memories of childhood incest recall being victims of
SRA. As mentioned above, many professionals believe that these are false memories -
memories of events that never happened.
Analyzing the recovered memories of SRA reveals internal flaws:
In one area, a group of SRA survivors all reported human sacrifices in which the bodies
were completely destroyed by burning in a bonfire. A skeptic later mentioned that fires
are not hot enough to destroy the evidence: bones would remain behind. After a while, the
survivors' stories changed. First one of them, and later all of them remembered bodies
being destroyed in undertakers' crematorium. So the police staked out these crematoria and
found no criminal activity was going on. After a while, the survivors' stories changed
again. This time, they remembered that bodies were destroyed in mobile crematoria owned by
the Satanists. These portable machines were hidden in caves and wheeled out during
rituals. If SRA really exists, then one would expect the survivor's recovered childhood
memories to be constant.
Survivors universally report very solemn Satanic ceremonies which are conducted without
error or distraction. Nobody ever drops a ritual tool; nobody ever cracks a joke; nobody
has problems lighting candles, etc. All rituals are perfect. If SRA really exists, then
one would expect the memories to include very human errors, just as they occur in other
religious settings.
A sizable proportion of survivors report that they were being trained to take over the
role of Chief Priestess or Chief Priest of the Satanic group. However, it is commonly
reported that such groups consist of 13 members. If SRA exists, then one would expect that
fewer than 1 in 6 survivors would report this training; more than 5 out of 6 would be
trained to become plain members.
21. SECRECY
If SRA existed, then every high priest, high priestess, POM (plain ordinary member),
and peripherally involved person would have sufficient information to blow the lid off of
the most important news story of the century. He/she could probably make hundreds of
thousands of dollars by selling their story to the media.
This has never happened.
22. LACK OF SRA DOCUMENTATION PRIOR TO 1980
There are no known 20th century SRA books or articles prior to the publishing of Michelle
Remembers in 1980. If SRA has been practiced for many generations (or even centuries
as many promoters of SRA believe) then someone should have come forward before 1980 to
document their activities.
WHAT IS THE REALITY OF SRA?
We conclude that SRA does not exist at any significant level. Ritual abuse is a very
small problem when compared to the level of conventional (non-ritual) physical and sexual
abuse of children (except of course to that rare individual who has been ritually abused).
WHAT IS THE FUTURE OF THE SRA INDUSTRY?
Promoters are having an increasingly difficult task convincing people of the reality of
SRA. Over two decades have passed since the publishing of Michelle Remembers in
1980, and there is still no hard evidence of any Satanic conspiracy. As memory researchers
and members of the False Memory Syndrome Foundation demonstrate how false memories
can be created in adults and children, we expect that the SRA scare will gradually fade.
However, if
an example of hard evidence can be found, or
an adult can be found with always present memories of SRA
then the SRA industry would be given a tremendous boost in credibility.
There are two indications that belief in SRA reached its peak in the early to
mid 1990's and is currently in
decline:
The number of calls to the False Memory Syndrome Foundation has decreased in
recent years. These are typically distressed parents whose adult child has recovered memories of sexual abuse during childhood. The percentage of
these calls that involve memories of SRA is constant at about 17%. So, the total number of
SRA calls is also in decline.
The number of books authored in a given year is a very crude indicator of how popular
the SRA hoax is. We sampled the Amazon on-line
bookstore for books which promoted the reality of ritual abuse. The books
were sorted by year of publication.
The results were:
1990 2 **
1991 3 ***
1992 1 *
1993 3 ***
1994 6 ******
1995 5 *****
1996 2 **
1997 3 ***
1998 1 *
1999 0
2000 0
Of the 37 books listed by Amazon.com in 2001-MAR-19, most were out
of print.
There is a
great deal of "noise" in this data. But it would seem that the interest in
SRA may reached a peak in the mid 1990's and is now in decline.
Sponsored link:
OTHER RESOURCES
An on-line copy of the FBI report on the (non)existence of evil
Satanic cults by Ken Lanning, titled "Investigator's Guide to Allegations of
'Ritual' Child Abuse" is available.
G.S. Goodman et al "Characteristics & Sources of Allegations of Ritual Child
Abuse", Clearing House on Child Abuse & Neglect Information, Suite 350, 3998
Fair Ridge Dr, Fairfax VA, 22033. [Free summary available by calling (703) 385-7565]
John Earl, "The Dark Truth About the 'Dark Tunnels of McMartin'",
Issues in Child Abuse Accusations, Vol. 7, #2, 1995 Spring, Institute for Psychological
Therapies, 13200 Cannon City Blvd., Northfield, MN 55057. An expose on the McMartin
pre-school underground tunnel myth. $15 USF; $20 USF (foreign).
Ellen Bass & Laura Davis, "The Courage to Heal, Harper Collins, New York
NY, (1992). The book accepts all memories uncovered during recovered memory therapy as
true.
Paul & Shirley Eberle, "The Abuse of Innocence : The McMartin Preschool
Trial", Prometheus Books (1993). ISBN: 0879748090. The authors attended the court
sessions lasting over many years, and concluded that there was no case against the
accused.