2007-APR-05: Russia: Human rights court rules in favor of
Scientology: In an unanimous decision, the European Court of Human
Rights determined that the Russian Federation's Moscow Justice
Department acted incorrectly by refusing to process multiple applications
for re-registration by the Church of Scientology Moscow as a religious
organization. They found that the Justice Department
"... did not act in good faith and neglected their duty of neutrality
and impartiality vis-à-vis the applicant's religious community”.
The Court also awarded the Church EUR 10,000 Euros for non-pecuniary
damage, costs, and expenses. 1,2
2007-OCT-05: Samoa: Police minister says Scientology no threat:
According toRadio New Zealand in Apia, Samoa:
"Tole’afoa Apulu Fa’afisi, says a goodwill
visit by Scientology volunteer ministers is crucial for the country as
their mission is to provide disaster seminars and training for
everyone."
"The minister, who opened the Scientology training program yesterday was
responding to more than a hundred Christian protesters from various
denominations who marched to show their disapproval of the
Scientologists visit."
"Tole’afoa says the government’s support for the Scientology volunteers
is for the important training they are providing which will teach people
how to survive disasters."
3
2007-NOV-01: Spain: Court
rules Scientology to be listed as a religion: The administrative
tribunal of Madrid's High Court ruled that an earlier decision by the
justice ministry decision to remove the church from the religious register
was:
"... against the law.
... As a result it is more correct, and within a liberal interpretation
which applies to the matter, to grant the requested inscription" in the
list of recognized religions. 4
2007-NOV-04: Belgium:
Government builds case against Scientology: A former member of the
Church in Belgium was unhappy with a course that she attended and attempted
to obtain a refund of 700,000 Belgium Francs (about U.S. $17,000) in course
fees. This triggered a decade-long investigation by Belgium prosecutors who
have allegedly concluded that the Church is a "criminal organization."
Lieve Pellens, a spokesperson for Belgium's Office of the Federal
Prosecutor is reported as saying:
"I always say that you are innocent until proven guilty, but we
really have enough elements and statements that we can prosecute them
for a number of crimes and misdemeanors."
The church describes the investigation as a "witch hunt." Fabio
Amicarelli, executive director of the European Scientology office is
reported as saying:
"The charges are totally false. "If it's so clear cut, why did it
take 10 years?"
Scientology attorney William Walsh said:
"The prosecutor's statement leaking this information to the press is
evidence that the heart of his case revolves around improperly
evaluating the religion and attempting to somehow characterize it as a
fraud."
He referred to a similar case in Italy where 67 Scientologists were
acquitted of fraud, criminal association and other charges in 1991. After an
appeal, the Italian Supreme Court ruled that Scientology met the
characteristics of a religion and that its practices were like those of
other religions. 5
References used:
The following information sources were used to prepare and update the above
essay. The hyperlinks are not necessarily still active today.
"European Court of Human Rights finds in favour of Scentology and against Russia in key registration case," Censur, 2007-APR-05, at:
http://www.cesnur.org/
"Church of Scientology Moscow versus Russia," Wikipedia, 2007-OCT-30, at: http://en.wikipedia.org/
"Samoa police minister says country is not endangered by Scientologists" Radio New Zealand, 2007-OCT-05, at: http://wwrn.org/
"Spanish court rules Scientology can be listed as a religion," AFP, 2007-NOV-01, at:
http://news.yahoo.com/
"Belgium builds case against Scientology. Prosecutors call the church a 'criminal organization.' The church says it's a 'witch hunt'," St. Petersburg Times, 2007-NOV-04, at:
http://www.sptimes.com/