Impact of appointments
to the U.S. Supreme Court
Court changes, 2005 to 2009
2005: Justice Sandra Day O'Connor's resignation:
On 2005-JUL-01, Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, 75, announced her resignation
from the U.S. Supreme Court. This produced the first vacancy on the court in 11
years. She had been viewed as moderately conservative, and a swing vote
The People for the American Way -- a liberal agency -- states
that: "With Justice O'Connor providing the swing vote on critical 5-4
decisions regarding privacy, reproductive rights, affirmative action,
government neutrality toward religion, and more, we cannot overstate the
profound impact her replacement could have on the direction of American law
and society." 1
Chairman James C. Dobson, founder of Focus on the Family
Action -- a Fundamentalist Christian group -- described Justice
O'Connor's resignation as "a watershed moment in American history: the
resignation of a swing-vote justice on the Supreme Court and the opportunity
to change the Court's direction." 2
||Another Fundamentalist Christian group, the
Family Research Council cites Justice O'Connor as providing the deciding
vote on many 5-4 decisions during the last few years such as:|
Mark Wexler of the Foundation for Autistic Childhood Education and
Support wrote: "During her 24 years on the
nation's highest court, her reasoning and findings evolved to shape the look
of today's court. She accomplished this by finding the ever-so-unpopular
middle ground and standing against extremes. Simply put, O'Connor shielded
the court - and our country - from unyielding ideologies." 7
President Bush decided to nominate Judge Roberts, a strict constructionist,
apparently from a desire to drive the court in the conservative direction for
many decades into the future. 11 Bush said the nominee "...has devoted his entire professional life to
the cause of justice and is widely admired for his intellect, his sound judgment
and personal decency." According to an unnamed administration official, Bush
interviewed Roberts on 2005-JUL-15, made his final decision on JUL-19, and
phoned Roberts about 12:30 PM to offer him the appointment. 12
Following Roberts' nomination, but before his confirmation by the Senate,
Chief Justice William Rehnquist died. President Bush then nominated Roberts to
be the new Chief Justice.
The 2005-APR filibuster controversy in the Senate
over the confirmation of lower court justices was not repeated. Judge Roberts'
nomination was easily confirmed by the Senate by a vote of 77 to 22. He was
installed as the 17th Chief Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court on 2005-OCT-03, in
time for the Fall sitting.
President Bush nominated Harriet Miers, also on OCT-03, to be Justice
O'Connor's replacement. Little is initially known about her political
philosophy, because she had never been a judge and thus has never issued a court
ruling. Massive opposition from social and religious conservatives caused Miers
2005: Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist's death:
Chief Justice Rehnquist had been suffering from thyroid cancer when his
health went into a drastic decline in late August, 2005. He died at home in
suburban Virginia during the evening of 2005-SEP-03 with his family present.
Rehnquist had consistently voted with the conservative block on the Supreme
Court which included Justices Scalia and Thomas. He was one of the five
conservative Justices nominated by Republican Presidents who voted to terminate
recount of the election results in Florida during the 2000 election, thus making
George W. Bush president. He was one of the two conservative justices who voted
against Roe v. Wade, the decision that provided abortion access for all American women
early in their pregnancies.
Judge Samuel Alito replaced Chief Justice Rehnquist. He is expected to have minimal impact on the balance
of the Supreme Court, because it is difficult to conceive of a replacement
justice who would be more consistently conservative than Rehnquist.
2009: Justice David Souter announced his resignation:
During 2009-APR, Justice David Souter, a moderate to liberal judge on the
court, announced his intention to retire. He had been appointed by
President George H.W. Bush in 1990 in the expectation that he would prove to be
a conservative. He surprised many observers by turning out to be a relative
liberal justice. This shift from conservative to liberal is a fairly common
transition for Supreme Court justices. As long as they are working at the Courts
of Appeal level, they have to follow the Supreme Court's precedents. However,
once on the Supreme Court, they can make precedents of their own.
This resignation gave President Obama his first opportunity to nominate a
justice to the Supreme Court and -- probably -- attempt to drive the court in a
more liberal direction. He selected Judge Sonia
Sotomayor as his replacement. If her nomination is confirmed, she would
become the Court's 111th justice in its two century history. She would be the
first Hispanic justice and the third woman to serve on the court.
As of 2009-JUL, four justices of the Supreme Court -- Chief Justice John
Roberts, and Justices Samuel Alito, Antonin Scalia, & Clarence Thomas appear to
follow a strict reconstructionist judicial philosophy. They tend to vote as a
conservative block on ethical and moral matters. All were appointed by
The block of four conservatives is counterbalanced with a group of five
moderates to liberals.
If affirmed, Sonia Sotomayor is a bit of an unknown. There are some
suggestions that she may prove to be a liberal justice:
||She said during her
confirmation hearings that she regards Roe v. Wade as "settled precedent,"
||She said that the court has found a personal guaranteed right to privacy
implied in several sections of the U.S. Constitution.
There is a significant possibility that Roe v. Wade will be challenged during
Obama's first term in an attempt to allow individual states to decide whether to
criminalize abortion. A lawsuit seeking the legalization of
same-sex marriages and challenging the
constitutionality of various defense of marriage acts (DOMA) may make it to the
Supreme Court early in the 2010s. Both could have a profound effect on American
The following information sources were used to prepare and update the above
essay. The hyperlinks are not necessarily still active today.
"Just Announced: O'CONNOR STEPS DOWN!," People for the American Way,
Pete Winn, "Justice O'Connor Retires; Battle over Swing-Vote Lies Ahead,"
CitizenLink, Focus on the Famlly, 2005-JUL-01, at:
"Encourage President Bush to name a CONSERVATIVE Justice," Take
Action Alert, Family Research Council, 2005-JUL-05.
Tim Harper, "Battle brews over Bus court nominee," The Toronto Star,
2005-JUL-20, Page A1 (front page.) Online at:
"Bush nominates Roberts to Supreme Court. Republicans praise nominee as
Dems vow thorough review," CNN News, 2005-JUL-20, at:
Antonin Scalaia, "God's Justice and Ours," First Things 123,
2002-MAY, Page 17 to 21.
Mark Wexler, "Supreme discontent," Sojourners, 2005-SEP-08, at:
Copyright © 2003 to 2009 by Ontario Consultants on
Latest update: 2009-JUL-16
Author: B.A. Robinson