WHY DID THE HURRICANE KATRINA HAPPEN?
Reasons given by some environmentalists

Sponsored link.

Essays discussing the beliefs of others are available elsewhere.

A brief review of the Katrina hurricane of 2005 (repeated):
On 2005-AUG-25, Katrina, as a Category 1 hurricane, struck south Florida. It
strengthened over the Gulf of Mexico to Category 4. It hit New Orleans, the rest
of Louisiana, and Mississippi on AUG-29.
As of SEP-06, the total death toll is unknown; it will probably exceed 1,000.
Hundreds of thousands of residents have been dislocated; a quarter million into Texas alone.
"The evacuees [from New Orleans], most of them black and poor, spoke of
violence, anarchy and family members who died for lack of food, water and
medical care." 1 Many have no homes, assets, or jobs to which to return.
Property damage is immense.

Reasons given by many spiritual and political environmentalists:
Deborah Caldwell, wrote a report for the Beliefnet web site titled: "Did God
Send the Hurricane? This natural disaster is bringing together a perfect storm
of environmentalist and religious doomsday sayers." She writes:
"Meanwhile, spiritual and political environmentalists say that massive
hurricanes such as Katrina, along with the Asian tsunami, are messages from
the earth, letting humanity know of the earth’s pain."
1

Reasons given by many spiritual environmentalists:
Many spiritual environmentalists follow the Gaia Hypothesis -- that the Earth
herself is a life form. This worldview has been widely held by people following
Aboriginal religions, Wicca
and other Earth-based Neopagan religions. James
Lovelock wrote a series books in which he promoted the Gaia hypothesis.
2,3 In Stephen Miller's review
of Lovelock's 1989 book, he wrote:
"What is the hypothesis of Gaia ? Stated simply, the idea is that we may
have discovered a living being bigger, more ancient, and more complex than
anything from our wildest dreams. That being, called Gaia, is the Earth."
"More precisely: that about one billion years after it's formation, our
planet was occupied by a meta-life form which began an ongoing process of
transforming this planet into its own substance. All the life forms of the
planet are part of Gaia. In a way analogous to the myriad different cell
colonies which make up our organs and bodies, the life forms of earth in
their diversity coevolve and contribute interactively to produce and sustain
the optimal conditions for the growth and prosperity not of themselves, but
of the larger whole, Gaia. That the very makeup of the atmosphere, seas, and
terrestrial crust is the result of radical interventions carried out by Gaia
through the evolving diversity of living creatures."
4
In this hypothesis, Gaia may sense a looming threat
to all forms of life on Earth due to the exploitation by humans of the Earth's
resources. It may be reacting like a bucking bronco, trying to rid herself of
this dangerous species of life in order to save countless numbers of other species. One
manifestation of this might be an increasing human death toll from tsunamis,
hurricanes, and tornados.

About the Gaia Hypothesis:
You might find one or more of the following books of interest. They are the
result of a search for "gaia hypothesis" in the Amazon.com data base. If you see a generic Amazon ad below, please
click on your browser's reload icon.

Reasons given by many political environmentalists:
Most political environmentalists probably accept the global
warming theory: that the extensive burning of fossil fuels generates higher
levels of greenhouse gasses. These gasses in the atmosphere are increasingly
trapping the sun's heat, similar to the panes of glass in a greenhouse. This causes the
earth's temperature to rise.
The Union of Concerned Scientists note that:
 | "Since the beginning of the 20th century, Earth's mean surface
temperature has increased by about 1.1°F (0.6°C)." |
 | "Warming in the 20th century is greater than at any time during the past
400 to 600 years." |
 | "The Arctic ice pack has lost about 40 percent of its thickness over the
past four decades." |
 | "Global sea level is rising about three times faster over the past 100
years compared with the previous 3,000 years."
5 This is resulting in the
flooding of low lying islands and coastal flooding. |
In its 2001 assessment, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
(IPCC) concluded that, "an increasing body of observations gives a collective
picture of a warming world and other changes in the climate system." Global
warming is disturbing weather patterns worldwide. In addition to the above four
symptoms,
global warming is causing:
 | Intervals of unusually elevated temperatures. |
 | Heat waves which kill thousands of vulnerable people. |
 | Major downpours, heavy snowfalls, and flooding. |
 | Periods of drought. |
 | Forest and prairie fires. |
 | Melting of glaciers. |
 | Warming of the Arctic and Antarctic producing shortening winters,
lengthening springs and thawing permafrost. |
 | Relocations of plant and animal species to cooler habitats. |
 | Bleaching of coral reefs. 6 |
Although there is a general consensus among scientists that global warming is a real phenomenon, there is no consensus on its cause or impact:
Hurricanes, tornados, and El Niños are heat-driven, and are thus intensified
by higher land and ocean temperatures. According to the Geophysical Fluid
Dynamics Laboratory (GFDL), a division of the Federal Government's
National Oceanic & Atmospheric Administration (NOAA):
"The strongest hurricanes in the present climate may be upstaged by even
more intense hurricanes over the next century as the earth's climate is
warmed by increasing levels of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere. Although
we cannot say at present whether more or fewer hurricane will occur in the
future with global warming, the hurricanes that do occur near the end of the
21st century are expected to be stronger and have significantly more intense
rainfall than under present day climate conditions. This expectation...is
based on an anticipated enhancement of energy available to the storms due to
higher tropical sea surface temperatures."
8
Two GFDL scientists, Thomas R. Knutson and Robert E. Tuleya, performed a
computer simulation study. They found that:
"...if the frequency of tropical cyclones remains the same over the
coming century, a greenhouse-gas induced warming may lead to a gradually
increasing risk in the occurrence of highly destructive category-5 storms."
8
Their simulations also show that Category 4
hurricanes may occur at about the same frequency, and that there may be a
reduction in Category 3 storms.
9
Thus, Katrina may be a harbinger of future
disasters.
In addition, there are many factors found in
Louisiana which exacerbated the effects of the hurricane:
 | Much of New Orleans is built below sea level.
So, when a levee was breached, about 80% of the city filled up like a
gigantic bathtub. |
 | Decades ago, there were miles of wetlands
between New Orleans and the Gulf of Mexico. According to Wes
Granberg-Michaelson, the general secretary of the Reformed Church in
America: "These act like a 'speed bump,' absorbing and lowering
some of a hurricane's force. But they've been disappearing, making way for
shopping malls, condos, and roads, so 25 square miles are lost each year -
an area the size of Manhattan. And the city has kept moving closer to the
Gulf." 10 |

About global warming:
You might find one or more of the following books of interest. They are the
result of a search for "global warming" in the Amazon.com data base. If you see a generic Amazon ad below, please
click on your browser's reload icon.

Beliefnet forum:
Some Internet surfers who read Deborah Caldwell's
essay on Beliefnet.com titled "Did God send the hurricane?" responded with
their views on the cause of Katrina's
devastation of the Gulf Coast. 1 We selected the following ten
which appear to be primarily motivated by environmental concerns:
 | "The 'Universal Energy' which some call G-d does not send floods nor
famine. We create our own realities and this is one of them. The weather is
changing due to environmental abuse there is not doubt but has nothing to do
with g-d. |
 | "This is not about God... It is about greed on the part of the oil
companies. It is about Global warming because we are using our natural
resources in excess... " |
 | "If anyone is to blame for the increase in hurricanes and their
severity, it is us. As global warming increased, the earth tries harder and
harder to cool itself and hurricanes are one way to remove the energy from
the oceans. The warmer it becomes, the more severe the storms are going to
be. This has to do with physical laws, not God's punishment on the unjust."
|
 | "Human pollution has added to climate change, creating more and stronger
hurricanes as nature deals with greenhouse gasses from human petrochemical
addiction. Therefore, it would be more honest to say that humans created
Katrina (specifically the Bush agenda to destroy the Kyoto accord on these
emissions)." |
 | "I think God is giving us a big hint that we'd better listen to our
Scientists about Environmental changes, and do something about them, as the
rest of the world is doing." |
 | "It's about time that we realized that the earth is a closed system and
very susceptible to small changes. Actually, it is amazing to me how
resilient that it has been up to this point. When you consider how we have
de-forested the planet, polluted the seas, and plundered the natural
resources, it's amazing to me that any of us are still here." |
 | "The Goddess Oya manifests hurricanes and tornadoes in order to renew
nature. Nature needs hurricanes as much as we need air. They are, like
earthquakes, the way the Earth keeps itself in balance." |
 | "We cannot treat the earth with contempt and expect it to shrug it off.
You may see only materialist nature in that equation, but I see the laws of
Karma (in the Christian view, reaping what you sow)." |
 | "As we continue to inflict damage on the planet, we can expect to see
more effects from nature as it attempts to reach equilibrium - and what's
frightening might be natures attempts to balance over population!" |
 | "God did not send this hurricane. I am so tired of people blaming God
when bad things happen. I believe it is the earth crying out to the people
living on it, to stop polluting, destroying etc. people need to wake up and
we all need to change. The sad thing is we are all to comfortable with our
lives to ever really change in order to stop global warming etc." |

References used:
The following information sources were used to prepare and update the above essay. The hyperlinks are not necessarily still active today.
-
Deborah Caldwell, "Did God
Send the Hurricane? This natural disaster is bringing together a perfect storm
of environmentalist and religious doomsday sayers," Beliefnet, circa
2005-SEP-03, at: http://www.beliefnet.com/
-
James Lovelock, "Ages of Gaia: A Biography of Our Living
Earth," W.W. Norton, (1988)
Read
reviews or order this book safely from Amazon.com online book store.
-
James Lovelock, "Gaia: A New Look at Life on Earth," Oxford
University Press, (2000).
Read
reviews or order this book safely from Amazon.com online book store.
-
Stephen Miller, "Gaia Hypothesis," 1989, at:
http://erg.ucd.ie/
-
"Global Environment: Global warming," Union of Concerned
Scientists, at:
http://www.ucsusa.org/
-
"Global warming: Early warning signs," Union of Concerned
Scientists and six other agencies, at: http://www.climatehotmap.org/
-
"Global Warming," Cooler Heads Coalition, at:
http://www.globalwarming.org/
-
"Global Warming and Hurricanes," Geophysical Fluid Dynamics
Laboratory, at: http://www.gfdl.noaa.gov/
-
"Idealized hurricane simulations," Image, Geophysical
Fluid Dynamics Laboratory, at:
http://www.gfdl.noaa.gov/
-
Wes Granberg-Michaelson, "Acts of God or sins of humanity?,"
Church Herald, 2005-OCT.

Site navigation:

Sponsored link.

Copyright © 2005 by Ontario Consultants on Religious
Tolerance Originally posted: 2005-SEP-06 Latest update: 2005-SEP-17 Author: B.A. Robinson
|