We ask you, humbly, to help us.

We hope you enjoy this web site and what it represents.
If so, fantastic!

The thing is ... we're an independent group of normal people who donate our time to bring you the content on this website. We hope that it makes a difference.

Over the past year, expenses related to the site upkeep (from research to delivery) has increased ... while available funds to keep things afloat have decreased. We would love to continue bringing you the content, but we desperately need your help through monetary donations. Anything would help, from a one-off to small monthly donations.

$3? $5? $15? The option is yours. Regardless, your help would be appreciated.

Please click HERE to be taken to our donation page. Thank you so much.
Bruce Robinson, Founder.


horizontal rule
2018-MAY: The UMC Council of Bishops'
recommendations for the 2019 UMC
Special General Conference on LGBT
equality topics. Conflicts.
horizontal rule

This topic is continued here from the previous essay

horizontal rule

A serious split has occurred in recent years within both the regular membership and the clergy of the United Methodist Church -- both in the U.S. and the rest of the world -- over its treatment of the lesbian, gay and bisexual (LGBT) community who are sexually active with members of the same sex. A denominationl schism is a major possibility if this conflict is not resolved. The Church's General Conference had asked their Council of Bishops to recommend a path forward to resolve the conflicts.

horizontal rule

Sponsored link

horizontal rule

Some of the main topics that have been under dispute are:

  • The status of persons in the denomination with homosexual and bisexual sexual orientations;

  • Whether same-sex marriages (a.k.a. gay marriages) should be opposed, tolerated, accepted, or promoted; and

  • Whether gay or bisexual candidates for the clergy who are sexually active with members of the same sex may be considered for ordination.

The Council organized a 32-member Commission on a Way Forward 1 to develop options for the future. The Commission developed three options:

  1. The Traditionalist Plan, which would maintain the Book of Discipline's current negative assessment of same-sex behavior, opposition to gay marriages, and rejection of same-sex sexually-active relationships. Many feel that this would cause a future split within the denomination, as attitudes towards the LBGT community gradually become more accepting within the UMC denominations, among Christians generally, and among North American adults generally.

  2. The One-Church Plan, which allows individual UMC conferences, churches, and pastors to reach, implement, and work within different approaches to homosexual topics. "The One-Church Plan would remove the current restrictive language of the UMC Book of Discipline section on homosexuality, and would add assurances to pastors and Conferences who -- due to their theological convictions -- sincerely believe that they cannot perform same-sex marriages or ordain self-avowed practicing homosexuals. 

  3. The Connectional Conference Plan. It would allow individual conferences to choose to affiliate with any one of:

    "... three connectional conferences. ... The connectional conferences would align based on theology or perspective on LGBTQ ministry — be it traditionalist, progressive or allowing for a variety of approaches. This plan would require multiple amendments to the denomination’s constitution."

The Council of Bishops held a meeting in Chicago to discuss, debate, and pray about the path forward. The majority of the Council of Bishops voted to recommend the "One-Church Plan" for possible adoption by the General Assembly. 2 One bishop indicated that the majority was "substantial;" another described it as "overwhelming." 3

They released a statement on 2018-MAY-04, announcing that a special session of the UMC General Conference will be held during 2019-FEB-23 to 26 in St. Louis, MI, to determine what changes the denomination will make, if any, to the UMC's official position on LGBT issues.

The outgoing Council of Bishops President, COB Bishop Bruce Ough, explained the Council of Bishops' decision:


Ken Carter, the newly installed President of the Council, said:

"With convicted humility, bishops want to be pastors and shepherds of the whole church in order to maximize the presence of a United Methodist witness in as many places in the world as possible and with as much contextual differentiation as possible. ..."

"The Council’s prayerful deliberation reflected the diversity of the global denomination on the matter of homosexuality and many other matters.  The Council affirms the strength of this diversity and our commitment to maintain the unity of the church." 2

Before being released publicly, the plans recommended by the Commission will undergo their finally editing and translation into all of the official languages of used by the General Conference. This is expected to be completed on or before 2018-JUL-08, which is the deadline for the submission of petitions for submission to the 2019-FEB Conference.

horizontal rule

Sponsored link

horizontal rule

2018-MAY-15: Confusion develops about the 2019 General Conference's agenda:

The main points of confusion are whether:

  • The Council of Bishops is forwarding to the General Conference all three proposals of their Commission on a Way Forward, or only the One-Church Plan.

  • Whether other petitions dealing with human sexuality, that are inconsistent with the bishops' report may also be submitted to the special General Conference. 3

  • A fee of $200 to $300 per attendee at the General Conference is planned. This was controversial.

horizontal rule

2018-MAY-15: Revisiting the defeat of two gender-based amendments at the 2016 General Conference:

During 2016, the United Methodist Commission on the Status and Role of Women introduced two constitutional amendments regarding equality between women and men, boys and girls in the Denomination. Similar amendments had been proposed for the past 28 years without success. In 2016, both amendments had obtained a majority vote in favor. However, both failed to attain the required 2/3rds majority vote by a small margin, and were thus defeated. 5

  • Amendment 1 will undergo a repeated vote at the 2020 General Conference because the wrong text version had been voted upon in 2016.

  • Amendment 2 will be reworded and re-introduced at the same Conference.

These amendments would have barred the denomination from discriminated against members because of their gender, ability, age, or marital status. This was not a problem for many UMC members. However, others noted that the terms "marital status" and "gender" were not specifically defined within the text of the amendments.

In recent years, two main controversies among Christians and between many religious individuals and secularists has involved the redefinition of both "marriage" and "gender:"

  • Marriage was once restricted in North America to two persons, who were of the same race, and opposite gender. Over time, persons of different races were allowed to marry in some U.S. states. This was made universal across the U.S. by a decision of the U.S. Supreme Court in 1967 in the case Loving v. Virginia. Similarly, the High Court allowed persons who were of the same gender to marry in their 2015 case Obergefell v. Hodges. Some UMC members would regard the Amendments as banning Church discrimination against persons who were legally married to a person of the same sex -- the majority of whom have a homosexual orientation. The members might regard the amendment as a sneak attack to change Church rules to allow openly sexually active homosexuals to be ordained.

  • Immediately after the high court ruling in Obergefell, religious conservatives in the U.S. switched much of their anti-gay effort to attack the rights of transgender persons. These are a small minority of persons who were identified as male or female at birth, but who now personally identify themselves as being of the opposite gender -- or -- less commonly -- of both genders, an intermediate gender, or as neither gender. Many UMC members regard transgender persons as being simply gender confused and in need of therapy; they might regard the amendment as a sneak attack to allow transgender persons to be treated within the denomination as being of a different gender from their birth-identified gender.

"Kevin" read the UMC Insight article 5 and posted a comment:

"The wording of the proposed amendments opened up some serious questions. Marital status could mean same sex marriage, polygamy, incestuous marriage, and child marriage. Did we really mean to lock that into our constitution? And just what does "ability" mean? If a pastor candidate is unable to execute his or her duties do we ordain that person anyway? I do not think the ramifications of these amendments were thought out." 5

horizontal rule

2018-JUL-28/29: "For Everyone Born" conference includes a panel disussion on the Way Forward report and its One-Church model:

A UMC panel discussion in St. Louis, MO, exposed a conflict within the LGBT community and its supporters about the One-Church model. Some favor the model because it allows UMC conferences, churches, and pastors flexibility on handling homosexual topics. But others oppose the model because it allows the same people to choose to continue to discriminate against the LGBT community. 6

The "For Everyone Born" weekend conference was sponsored by the Love Your Neighbor coalition. The latter's name is derived from Matthew 22:36-40 in the Bible where Jesus instucts Christians to:

" ... love God with all our heart, soul (being) and mind" and to "love one's neighbor as one's self."

The coalition is a "... partnership of 13 United Methodist Church related Caucus groups working for a just, inclusive and grace filled denomination."

Their stated mission is:

"... to assure [that] The United Methodist Church is fully open to the presence, love and grace of God offered to all people." 7

horizontal rule

2018-AUG-20: The Hispanic/Latino Caucus supports the one-church model:

The group "Methodists Associated Representing the Cause of Hispanic/Latino Americans" (MARCHA) met for four days at Charlotte, NC, starting on 2018-AUG-02. They discussed the three LGBT models proposed as paths forward for the United Methodist Church to handle their LGBT minority. MARCHA delegates voted in favor of the One-Church plan.

Eunice Vega spoke in favor of the One-Church plan. She said:

"We have brought this proposal because this is the model that — we believe — provides more possibilities for the coexistence of different theological positions. ... [It] gives space to local churches, conferences, clergy and laity, to be able to assume their positions conscientiously, and accordingly with their contexts."

She noted that the UMC has often held conflicting opinions in the past, particularly over matters like slavery and the ordination of women. She continued:

""On the other hand, the other [two] plans (Traditionalist and Connectional Conference) do not make clear the future of the general agencies. As a Hispanic-Latino caucus, whose mission is to advocate for the rights of the United Methodist Hispanic-Latino people, we believe that the existence of agencies is a fundamental tool for this mission."

She feels that many of the agencies and UMC organizations:

"... would probably disappear with the adoption of any of the other two models."

Rev. Rosita Mayorga, North Central Jurisdiction, argued against supporting the One-Church Plan. She said:

"This resolution will have a negative impact on our congregations, since most are charismatic. Although I do not think they are fundamentalists, but most of them are certainly conservative. ... The situation is painful, because it has taken a lot to build congregations, which could leave the denomination if this model is adopted at the special General Conference in 2019." 8

horizontal rule

2018-AUG-22: African leaders support the Traditional Plan:

The UMC is growing in Africa. About 30% of the delegates to the General Conference come from African countries.

Rev. Jerry Kulah is the dean of Gbarnga School of Theology in Liberia, and a Conference delegate. He organized the Africa Initiative which trains delegates about how the Conference works and how to participate.

African delegates strongly oppose liberalizing UMC rules regarding homosexuality. Rev. Kulah said:

"It’s not an issue of the church law remaining the same. It’s an issue of what the Bible teaches, and the Bible teaches one man, one woman for life, as far as marriage is concerned." 9

Webmaster's comment:

While it is true that the Bible regards marriage as a heterosexual institution, polygamy was one of eight marriage types mentioned in the Bible. Solomon holds the record among polygamous marriages. He had 700 wives of royal birth along with 300 concubines.

African delegates to the 2019 General Conference are expected to vote for the Traditional Plan -- the most conservative of three plans created as options by the UMC Council of Bishops, that would continue the UMC's discrimination against the LGBT community.

horizontal rule

This essay will be augmented as more details become available.

horizontal rule

References used:

The following information sources were used to prepare and update the above essay. The hyperlinks are not necessarily still active today.

  1. "Commission on a Way Forward: About Us," UMC, 2018, at: http://www.umc.org/
  2. Council of Bishops "United Methodist Bishops Recommend a Way Forward," UMC, 2018-MAY-04, at: http://www.umc.org/
  3. Sam Hodges and Heather Hahn, "Bishops' Action Leads to Questions," United Methodist Insight, 2018-MAY-15, at: http://um-insight.net/
  4. Video by Todd Rossnagel. "Bishops recommend a way forward for UMC," at: https://www.facebook.com/
  5. Kathy L. Gilbert, "Women Grieve Amendment Failures, Vow to Work Harder," United Methodist Insight, 2018-MAY-15, at: http://um-insight.net/
  6. "Way Forward: Talks & Marketing," United Methodist Insight, Email sent on 2018-AUG-03.
  7. "Love Your Neighbour Coalition," undated at: http://lyncoalition.org/
  8. Gustavo Vasquez, "Hispanic/Latino Caucus Supports One-Church Plan," United Methodist Insight, 2018-AUG-20, at: https://um-insight.net/
  9. Sam Hodges, "Africans poised for clout at GC2016," UMC Nws, 2016-MAY-09, at: https://www.umnews.org/
  10. E. Julu Swen, "African Leaders Support Traditional Plan," United Methodist Insight, 2018-AUG-22, at: https://um-insight.net/

How you may have arrived here:

 Home page > Christianity > Mainline Christian conflicts > UMC > here

or Home page > Conflict > Homosexuality > Churches > UMC > here

Original posting: 2018-MAY-10
Latest update: 2018-AUG-24
Author: B.A. Robinson

line.gif (538 bytes)
Sponsored link

Go to the previous page, or return to the UMC and Homosexuality menu, or choose:

Go to home page  We would really appreciate your help

E-mail us about errors, etc.  Hot, controversial topics

FreeFind search, lists of new essays...  Having problems printing our essays?

Twitter link

Facebook icon

GooglePage Translator:

This page translator works on Firefox,
Opera, Chrome, and Safari browsers only

After translating, click on the "show
original" button at the top of this
page to restore page to English.