Fear of the millennium - among conservative Christians:
Many Fundamentalist and other Evangelical Christian authors wrote books which
attempt to raise public consciousness (some would say hysteria) about the Y2K problem and
the arrival of the Millennium. These include:
J. Gregori, Ed., "What Will Become of Us? Counting down to Y2K,"
Academic Freedom Fdn., (1008) Review/Order
this book
M. Hyatt & G. Grant, "Y2K: The day the world shut down," Word
Publ., (1998). A novel. Review/Order
this book
G.R. Jeffries, "The Millennium Meltdown: The year 2000 computer crisis,"
Frontier Research, (1998). Review/Order
this book
Shaunti Feldhahn was a Federal Reserve analyst, and the author of
"Y2K: The Millennium Bug -- A Balanced Christian Response"
She polled fellow Christians and found that about:
60% were taking no action about the millennium
25% were making active preparations or were planning to start soon
10% were actively opposed to any preparation,. They often quote Matthew
6:25 in which Christ tells people to not worry about the future.
A few percent adopted an extreme survivalist position. 1,2
Leaders in promoting Y2K hysteria were Fundamentalist Christians James Dobson, Jerry
Falwell, Grant Jeffries, Jack
Van Impe, Hal Lindsey, Gary North, and Pat Robertson. Their teachings continued to be highly
alarmist even as the end of 1999 approached. At that time, evidence was
generally known that industry, government and commerce were on
target to slay the bug before 2000-JAN-1.
As of 2000-DEC-30, Gary North's web site was still accessible, apparently in
its pre-2000 form "with what one journalist labels 'its laughable
predictions of global chaos.' " 3,8During 2001, the
web site was removed. The essay is still available on some mirror sites.Most of the other
alarmist webmasters and authors had long since counted their profits on the way
to the bank, perhaps chuckling at how easy it was to make so much money by
engender panic among conservative Christians.
The end result of alarmist publications was needless, widespread hysteria
among Christian believers, and a great deal of profit in the pockets
of the authors. Some commentators stated that conservative Christians deserved more responsible treatment
from their leadership. One Evangelical commented "If the money changers
of Jesus' time lived today, they would probably be selling Y2K supplies."
Sponsored link:
The potential for violence:
There is a potential for violence, both short term and longer term:
FBI director Louis Freeh warned on 1999-FEB-4 that: "With the coming of the
next millennium, some religious/apocalyptic groups or individuals may turn to violence as
they seek to achieve dramatic effects to fulfill their prophecies." He also
talked about another disturbing religious trend: "Many white supremacist
groups adhere to the Christian Identity belief system, which holds that the world is on
the verge of a final apocalyptic struggle... and teaches that the white race is the chosen
race of God." He warned that in late 1999, some Christian Identity members might
prepare for their anticipated Armageddon by committing robberies to finance their
activities. The government, Jews and non-whites are said to be likely targets.
4 These fears did not materialize.
There is a remote potential of longer term violence in North America, starting perhaps around
2002. Large numbers of people expect the end of the world and the return of Christ in the
year 2000, or 2001. If, as most commentators expect, the world continues as normal, there will be a truly
massive disappointment, affecting tens of millions of Christians. Some
may be terribly
disillusioned, and will start searching for reasons why the end times did not happen.
There is the possibility that some religious leaders might return to preaching a
widespread belief that was held in the 19th century: that Jesus' second coming is being
delayed until many more people are converted to Christianity. Those same leaders might
point to the rise in popularity among minority religions, and the
decline of Christianity in North America as a major factor which is
delaying Christ's return. The result could be violence by a very small
percentage of Christians directed against small religious
groups in North America: Jews, Muslims, followers of the
New Age, Wiccans, other
Neopagans, etc. There is also the possibility of Christians turning against their own
leaders and groups who had raised end-time anticipation to a fever pitch. We might see a
replication of the events in the year 1000 when many disillusioned people in Western
Europe attacked the established church.
Confidence in the Millennium
There were signs during 1999 that some are viewing the Millennium as an unremarkable event:
There was a rise of rational belief, that the year 2,000 is simply a year that
has three zeros. i.e. it is in no way special. After all, if humans had been born with 8
fingers on each hand, then our numbering system would be based on 16 (hexadecimal), not 10
(decimal). And our year 2,000 would then just be year 8D0 in hexadecimal. Nothing special;
just another year with an unremarkable number.
Harvard professor of zoology and geology Stephen Jay Gould pointed out that the word
millennium was originally a Biblical apocalyptic term linked to the second coming
of Jesus. It is evolving into a matter-of-fact designation
for the end of a 1000 year period. "The basic reason for 'millennium' switching
from a description of the future to a counting in the present stems from the failure of
this expected future to materialize." 5
Michael R LeGault, a journal editor and reviewer of science books noted:
"The millennial message would appear to be that knowledge based on experience has
won out over knowledge based on doctrine...this knowledge is a record of both our
intellectual and moral progress. And that only in rational pursuit and use of this
knowledge is our physical, emotional and spiritual well-being ensured."
6
The banking industry had been working on the Y2K problem for years. The problem first
materialized for them when they started issuing mortgages in the 1970's which matured in
the 21st century. Since then, they have had to modify their computer code to
handle credit card expiry dates in the year 2000 and beyond. They took the Y2K
problem in stride.
Large companies had also been working on this problem for many years and
were in good shape when the year 2000 arrived.
Events in the months leading up to Y2K:3
As the year 2000 approached, news was relatively comforting:
Overall: Senator Robert F. Bennett, (R-UT) headed a Senate committee examining the issue. He
felt
that disruptions would be minor: "I'm very optimistic that this is not the
end of Western civilization as we know it."
Telephones: AT&T had fixed and tested all of its phone and data systems. They expected that any
unexpected glitches will materialize in billing and network-management problems, not in
actual transmission difficulties.
Airplanes: Boeing found only three Y2K bugs in its planes' software.
Medicare: Medicare renovated, tested and validated its 25 most critical computer systems.
Overall: John A. Koskinen, chief Y2K advisor to President Clinton
likened the effect of the bugs
to a powerful winter storm: producing minor problems for some and severe but short-term disruptions
for others. "We still don't know how many storms there will be, but the risk is
localized storms, not national debacles." He predicted that 85 to 90% of U.S.
Federal government conversion work will be completed by the deadline of 1999-MAR-31.
In retrospect, his predictions appear to have been unduly
pessimistic.
Banks: The Federal Reserve had given U.S. banks a 1999-OCT deadline to have removed any Y2K
bugs, and to have verified that their programs will survive the year end.
Money: An extra 50 to 75 billion worth of bank notes of all denominations
were made
available late in 1999 to handle an expected large drain on bank accounts.
Industry: Chase Manhattan Corp. expected to pay $363 million to fix their Y2K bugs. E.I. DuPont de
Nemours expected to spend $400 million. The worldwide cost was expected to be between $300
and $600 billion dollars. Litigation and insurance costs are expected to boost this to
over $1 trillion dollars. Relatively few disruptions were experienced at the
end of 1999. The trillion dollar estimate is probably excessive.
Government: As of mid 1999-JAN, two states planned to mobilize the National Guard for
2000-JAN-1. However, they did not call it a mobilization, because that might alarm folks.
They are calling it a training exercise.
Foreign Governments:
Russia turned down help offered by the U.S. and NATO to revamp its nuclear missile
and early-warning defense systems to remove any Y2K bugs. They were suspicious that this
offer was a cover operation to spy on Russian facilities.
China has found the ultimate technique to assure that its airlines will be free of any
Y2K problems. They ordered its airline chiefs to be airborne on New Years Day, 2000.
Canada's armed forces are organizing Operation Abacus which
had almost
20,000 troops available for up to 30 days service in 2000-JAN. The name of the program
was
well chosen: an abacus is a calculating machine that is totally mechanical in operation,
and will thus be useable even if the electricity fails.
Airlines: The International Air Transportation Association (IATA)
predicted that the world's
airlines will spend about $2.3 billion (U.S. funds) to wipe out the bug.
Electricity: There had been a number of tests of the electrical
grid during 1999:
The electrical utility serving the Canadian province of Nova Scotia set the computer
clocks ahead into 2000 without incident.
The electrical utility, Ontario Hydro, conducted a test on 1999-MAR-7 at
midnight. It involved the electrical service of 500,000 people in western Toronto, ON.
They set the clock on various systems ahead to the year 2000 to confirm that all of the
millennium bugs were eradicated. Streetcars and subway trains stopped at the nearest
convenient station at 11:55 PM as a precaution in case the power failed. Otherwise,
stalled streetcars could block intersections, and people using the subway could be trapped
in tunnels. Bars scheduled extra bouncers in case of disturbances that might be caused by
a power failure. O.H. spokesperson, Al Manchee, said: "The test was a complete
success. All the equipment performed as we expected." There wasn't even a
flicker.
There was a massive test of the communications systems of North American electrical
utilities on 1999-APR-9. All of the more than 3,000 electric utilities in the U.S. and
Canada participated. They pretended that their inter-utility communication systems had
broken down and had to be replaced by a manual backup. They reported that their
communications contingency plans had no serious problems. Most worked well; some areas
which can be improved have been highlighted. A second test was scheduled
for 1999-SEP-9.
Airplanes: The U.S. Federal Aviation Administration tested the air traffic control
facilities in Denver, CO on 1999-APR-11. No problems were noted.
Governments: The start of the fiscal year in Japan, Canada and New York State passed on 1999-APR-1
without incident. APR-6 marked the start of Britain's fiscal year. Again, the date passed
uneventfully.
Airplanes: The U.S. Transportation Department lacked sufficient data to predict
whether 17 international destinations will be Y2K ready. They stated: "Prudence...dictates
that travelers electing to fly in the civil aviation system of [these
destinations] during the period immediately before and after the New Year
should plan their itinerary carefully." They maintain a web site to
help keep travelers informed. 7
When New Year 2000 finally arrived, few systems failures were observed.
Y2K Definitions:
A new series of terms has been created to cover the Y2k problem:
Clean management: Making certain that replacement software and hardware
for Y2K compliant computers are themselves compliant.
Embedded systems: Electronic circuitry within electrical and electronic
equipment that contains microprocessors. These are small computing devices with limited
functionality. They are not programmable by the end user and are often not even known
about. But they have some of the functionality of regular computers and may fail due to a
Y2K bug.
Millennium bug: An inability of computer software or hardware to handle
the transition from the year 1999 to 2000.
Mission-critical systems: Computer systems whose failure would greatly
impact an organization's ability to function. Process control systems are perhaps the best
example of this; they control manufacturing systems on a minute-by-minute basis. Their
failure could shut down a plant, electrical generator, communication system, etc.
Rip-and-replace: Rather that repairing the hardware and software of a
computer system to make it Y2k compliant, the hardware and/or software is discarded and
replaced with more modern equivalents.
Y2K: an abbreviation of the year 2000. One wag
noticed that this sort of abbreviation is the type of shorthand that
got us into the original mess.
Y2K compliant: The status of a computer system that is either
unaffected by the millennium bug or has been fixed so that it can handle the transition
from the year 1999 to 2000 without failing.
References:
Shaunti Feldhahn, "Y2K: The Millennium Bug -- A Balanced Christian
Response" Multinornah Publ., (1998) Read a
review or buy this book