Overview of abortion: An
Part 3 of 3:
Conflicting beliefs about
abortion access (Cont'd).
Status of the pro-life and
pro-choice groups. Abortion
access in the U.S. & Canada
Re: Aborted fetuses born alive:
Conflicting beliefs about abortion access (Continued):
Some people would only allow legal abortions in one or more of the
Again, few if any polls ask these questions.
- If an abortion is needed to save the life of the woman, or
To prevent the woman from experiencing permanent and serious disability, or
To prevent the woman developing serious health problems.
When the fetus is so malformed that it will only live a matter
of hours after birth.
When the fetus has a serious chromosome abnormality -- e.g. those that
cause Down Syndrome.
When the pregnancy was the result of rape or incest.
A small minority believe that all abortions should be banned, even
if needed to save the life of the mother. According to
the same polls, between 12% and 25% of American adults held this
position. We feel that it is naive for the media to imply that there is a unity of belief within the pro-life and within the pro-choice movements.
Status of the two groups and of abortion access in the U.S.:
Both the pro-life and pro-choice movements are powerful and active. Pro-life groups are particularly influential at
the state level and have successfully persuaded legislators and governors to create many state laws that severely restrict abortion. Many of the
laws have been ineffectual; they are so broadly worded that court injunctions suspend them shortly after having been signed into law.
Courts often find that these laws are so vaguely worded that physicians are unable to determine whether a specific act is allowed or
prohibited. Those laws which survive court challenges are not particularly effective; they often merely have the effect of generating a delay before a woman can obtain an abortion, or of making it more probable that women seeking an abortion will go to a nearby state.
Approval of the abortion drug RU-486 has forever change abortion in America. Doctors are now able to
prescribe the pills and women may be able to take the pill at their
homes. Rural women will not have to drive long distances to abortion
clinics. Women will not have to run the gauntlet of abortion protestors.
2018-NOV-23: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) issued a report on abortion numbers in the U.S.:
Their report dealt with abortions during 2015. They found:
The total number of surgical abortions was 638,169. This included: "surgical abortions, intrauterine instillations, medical [non surgical] abortions, and hysterectomies/hysterotomies. (Intrauterine instillations refers to "... a rarely used method of late term abortion, performed by injecting a solution into the uterus.")
The rate of abortions was 11.8 abortions per 1,000 women of childbearing age (15 to 44 years)
The ratio of abortions was 188 abortions per 1,000 live births. 13,14 That is, about 16% (one in six) of all pregnancies are aborted.
During 2014, six women died as a result of complications from legally induced abortions in the U.S.
Unfortunately, these numbers are underestimates because individual states are not required to report abortion information to the CDC. California, Maryland, and New Hampshire have not reported data for at least eight years.
During the interval 2006 to 2016:
The total number of abortions dropped by 24%.
The rate of abortions dropped by 26%.
The ratio of abortions dropped by 19%. 14
Various factors are believed to have driven these numbers lower:
- Higher levels of comprehensive sex education in schools.
- Greater use of contraceptive to prevent conception.
- Fewer abortion clinics. Seven states have only one clinic in operation.
- Availability of the "morning after pill" that prevents conceptions.
- Availability of cheap test strips that detect very early pregnancy.
- Greater availability of RU-486 medication from physicians that terminate early pregnancies without surgery.
- Increasing number of pro-life pregnancy care centers whose goal is to discourage women from having abortions.
- Ultrasound technology which persuades many women to not have an abortion.
- Increased number of abortion-restricting state laws: 260 during the previous five years and over 540 since the year 2010.
The CDC also reported on when during pregnancy surgical abortions were performed in 2015. They found:
- 65% were performed on embryos (8 weeks gestation or less gestation).
- 35% were performed on fetuses (more than 8 weeks gestation).
- 92% were performed before 21 weeks gestation. This is about three weeks before the fetus' higher brain functions first turn on and the fetus is able to sense its environment to some degree.
- 59.3% of abortions were performed on women who had had one or more previous live births.
- 56.3% of abortions were performed on women who had never had a previous abortions.
2019-SEP: In the U.S., both the number and the rate of abortions drop:
Abortion rates have dropped to their lowest value since the U.S. Supreme Court issued its ruling on the Roe v. Wade case, which liberalized access to abortion in 1973. The Guttmacher Institute said:
"The US abortion rate dropped to 13.5 abortions per 1,000 women aged 15--44 in 2017, the lowest rate recorded since abortion was legalized [across the country] in 1973." 15
The abortion number declined by 196,000 per year (19%) between 2011 and 2017.
The abortion rate declined from 16.9 to 13.5 per 1,000 women aged 15 to 44, (20%) between 2011 and 2017. The rate increased in only 5 states and the District of Columbia.
The Guttmacher Institute attributes the decline in abortion rate to:
- A reduction in the number of women who are becoming pregnant.
- The increase in access to contraception since 2011.
The Affordable Care Act still requires most private health insurance plans to provide contraceptives at no cost to the individual.
- The almost 400 state laws restricting abortion access that were passed between 2011 and 2017. However, they do not believe that this is a major cause of the reduction, because they found that the rate reduction was similar among states that passed restrictive laws and those that did not. Restricting access probably causes many women to simply travel to an adjacent state that does not restrict access.
- Many women are using the abortion pill to terminate pregnancies in their early stage rather than relying on abortion. This may be the main cause of the reduction in abortions because use of the "abortion pill" increased from 29% of pregnancy terminations in 2014 to 39% in 2017.
The abortion rate and number may increase in the future. The Trump Administration has modified the Title X federal family planning program. It funds clinics that provide contraceptive information to women with low incomes who want to prevent becoming pregnant. The Administration passed a regulation that prohibits the clinics from referring women to abortion clinics. About 20% of family planning clinics that were in the Title X program have left it because of the regulation. Alina Salganicoff, director of women’s health policy at the Kaiser Family Foundation said:
"If your priority is to reduce abortions, one of the best things you can do is make sure that women have access to high-quality, affordable and effective methods of birth control."
Prohibiting Title X funded clinics from referring clients will probably prove ineffective, because most clients can easily find their own referrals to abortion clinics via local community information centers or through the Internet.
Status the pro-life and pro-choice groups and of abortion access in Canada:
The pro-life movement lost most of its funding from religious sources after some groups started to harass abortion providers in the
vicinity of their homes. This also generated fear among the families and neighbors of the providers. During the late 1990's, two Canadian pro-life groups lost
their charitable status with Revenue Canada because of excessive political activity.
Abortion protests now fail to attract large
numbers of supporters. The groups now do little more than conduct candlelight vigils, and issue press releases. One exception is the annual March for Life which is held at the nation's capital in Ottawa, Ontario each May. After the 2017 march, Life News reported that:
"... an estimated 25,000 people [had] attended [in 2016], and organizers hoped to break the record this year. ..."
"Photos and social media posts ... indicate that the  crowd size probably did break the record, but LifeNews could not find an official estimate. The CBC reported 'hundredsâ€ of people attended the march, but mainstream news outlets tend to vastly underestimate March for Life numbers." 11
Abortion access is rarely is discussed in the media. The country has many laws that promote the safety of abortions, but has no law that regulates access to abortion. That function has been taken over by provincial and territorial medical associations which have regulations that limit how late in pregnancy an abortion can be performed and for what reasons.
In recent years, social and religious conservatives have been forging strong bonds with the Conservative Party of Canada, similar to the formation of the Moral Majority and Religious Right movements in the U.S. during the late 20th century. Prior to 2015-OCT, the Conservative Party had insufficient members in the Canadian Parliament, and was only been able to influence laws and regulations on relatively minor moral issues, like:
- Terminating foreign aid relating to abortion.
Gutting government funding to various women's movements in the country.
Terminating funding programs that had enabled groups to challenge government human rights violations through the courts.
- Unsuccessfully attempting to re-open debate on same-sex civil marriage (a.k.a. gay marriage) in Parliament.
The Christian Heritage political party is strongly pro-life. However, it only fielded 30 candidates among the available 338 seats in Parliament, only received 0.09% of the public vote and failed to elect a single candidate. 12
At the 2015-OCT federal election, the Liberal Party of Canada regained its majority position. Abortion access appears secure. However, if the Conservative Party were able to obtain a majority in the House of Commons in the future, then it is quite probable that the Conservatives would quickly tackle major moral issues, by:
- Re-establishing the death penalty.
Restricting or eliminating abortion access.
Terminating future gay marriages and perhaps forcibly divorcing existing same-sex couples.
and perhaps even
Re-criminalizing consensual same-sex sexual behavior.
Canada's political system is structured very differently from the U.S. These major moral issues must be fought on a state-by-state basis in the U.S., but can be changed simultaneously in every province and territory across Canada by a single federal law.
Special cases:Aborted fetuses born alive:
In rare instances, aborted fetuses are alive when born. There were 143 such instances were observed during the 24 months of the years 2003 and 2004. Some Republican lawmakers, both federal and state, have tried to pass legislation requiring doctors to provide livesaving care to such infants. The Associated Press wrote:
"Organizations representing obstetricians and gynecologists say the law already provides protections to newborns, whether born during a failed abortion or under other circumstances. But when anomalies are so severe that a newborn would die soon after birth, a family may choose what’s known as palliative care or comfort care. This might involve allowing the baby to die naturally without medical intervention.
On 2020-SEP-23, President Donald Trump promised to sign an executive order that would require health care providers to provide medical care to all babies born alive. He said:
"This is our sacrosanct moral duty."
Jacqueline Ayers, a vice president of the Planned Parenthood Action Fund, said:
"It seems this administration will once again seek a solution to a nonexistent problem. Health care providers already have an obligation to provide appropriate medical care." 17
- American statistics are listed by Baptists for Life, Inc. at: http://www.bfl.org/stats
- Canadian statistics are listed by Action Life (Ottawa) Inc. at: http://www.ncf.carleton.ca/
- Bob Enyart is an extremely conservative talk show host. He has a "Bob
Enyart Live Abortion Clock" on his web site. It lists the total number of
legal abortions that have been performed since 1973. See: http://www.enyart.com/
- Carl Sagan, "Billions and Billions: Thoughts on Life and Death at
the Brink of the Millennium: Chapter 15" Read
reviews or order this book safely from Amazon.com online book store Chapter 15 has been reprinted at: http://www.2think.org/
- S. Boyd, "Give us liberty: The approval of RU-486 isn't about
morals, it's about options," Salon.com at: http://www.salon.com/
(This may be a temporary posting)
- A.T. Hyman, "The 'A' Word." This is an essay on the legal
aspects of the abortion debate. See: http://members.aol.com/
- Nellie Gray, president of March for Life, at the 28th annual March
for Life, 2001-JAN-22.
- "Constitution Party supports statewide abortion ban,"
Stop Abortion in Ohio, undated, at: http://www.ohioabortionban.com/
- "Sanctity of Life," Platform, Constitution Party at: http://www.constitutionparty.com/
- Marci McDonald, "The Armageddon Factor," Random House Canada. Released 2010-MAY-11.
Micaiah Bilger, "Thousands of Pro-Lifers Flood the Streets in Canadaâ€™s March for Life," 2017-MAR-11, at: http://www.lifenews.com/
"Canadian Federal Election 2015," Wikipedia, as on 2017-MAY-15, at: https://en.wikipedia.org/
Tom Strode, "Abortion decline calls for ongoing pro-life effort," Baptist Press, 2018-DEC-06, at: http://www.bpnews.net/
"Abortion Surveillance â€" United States, 2015," Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), 2018-NOV-23, at: https://www.cdc.gov/
"Number of Abortions in US Falls to Lowest Level Since 1973," Snopes, 2019-SEP-18, at: https://www.snopes.com/
Kevin Freking, "Trump works to win over Catholic voters on abortion issue," Associated Press, 2020-SEP-23, at: https://apnews.com/
Copyright Â© 1996 to 2019 by Ontario Consultants on Religious Tolerance
Last updated 2019-SEP-21
Author: Bruce A Robinson