Religious change, conflict and/or intolerance
News items during 2007-March
||2007-FEB-08: Humbolt SK, Canada: Catholic Church not allowed to run
hospital: There have been many instances in North America where the
Roman Catholic Church has taken over the operation of hospitals. When this
happens, they typically shut down family planning clinics and ban operations
like tubal ligations and vasectomies which are intended to terminate
people's fertility. This is consistent with the Church's teaching that every
act of sexual intercourse must be open to conception. This means that any
artificial means of contraception, such as the use of "the pill" or condoms
are profoundly sinful, as are operations to prevent future conceptions. It
also means that physicians and the hospital administration involved in these
operations for the purpose of contraception would also be performing sinful
During 2006-JUL, St. Elizabeth's hospital banned all future tubal
ligations. During 2006-DEC, its policies were updated. They now state that
"sterilization may be permitted when the primary purpose is to benefit the
total health of the person." However, the preamble to the policy states that
sterilization would not be permitted for the sole purpose of
contraception. Presumably this would cover vasectomies as well. Dr. Jackie
Bourgeois, and Dr. Carrie Levick resigned from the hospital because they
felt that the could no longer provide proper care to their patients.
A major controversy surfaced. Humboldt and surrounding communities had
previously agreed to contribute $13 million for the new Humbolt Uniplex that
is to replace the 85 year old St. Elizabeth's hospital. They decided to
withdraw their support, if the new hospital is run by a Catholic board. The
Saskatchewan Health Region decided that Uniplex the will be run as a public
institution rather than by Saskatchewan Catholic Health Corporation.
Presumably, tubal ligations and vasectomies will once more become available
to adults in their catchment area. 1,2
||2007-MAR-06: U.S. State Department releases annual human rights
report: The Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor of the U.S.
Department of State released its Country Reports on Human Rights Practices
for 2006. Sadly, although the report catalogs human rights abuses and
victories in over 175 countries, it neglects the U.S. itself. See:
||2007-MAR-27: Lawsuit charging FAIR with being unfair was dismissed:
Jerald and Sandra Tanner are founders of Utah Lighthouse Ministry --
an anti-Mormon Evangelical Christian group. They charged The Foundation
for Apologetic Information & Research (FAIR) with trademark infringement
and unfair competition. FAIR is a pro-Mormon group that had set up ten
domain names, including utahlighthouse.com and htalightouse.org that led to
a single web site which closely resembles the Lighthouse site, and is a
parody of it. The domain names have since been transferred to Lighthouse.
2007-MAR-27: Israeli Conservative Jewish seminary remains closed:
Rabbi Einat Ramon, dean of the Schechter Rabbinical Seminary in
Jerusalem announced that her seminary would remain closed to gay and lesbian
students. She said:
"This is a final decision. In Israel, the [Conservative] movement has
to be consistently halachic [true to rabbinic and biblical law]
otherwise it will unite with the Reform Movement."
She stated that she believes that homosexuality is a chosen behavior, not
a fixed sexual orientation. 6 More info.
||2007-MAR-28: Debate about religion held in
London, UK: Professor and well-known Atheist Richard Dawkins, Professor
A.C. Grayling of the University of London, and columnist Christopher
Hitchens debated Rabbi Julia Newberger, philosopher Roger Scruton and
archeologist Nigel Spivey on the topic "We'd be better off without
religion?" Dawkins suggested that religion is like "... a
child with a dummy in its mouth. I do not think it a very dignified or
respect-worthy posture for an adult to go around sucking a dummy for
comfort." A dummy is a British term for a infant pacifier. He said that
giving children a religious education was comparable to "... erecting a
firewall in their minds" against scientific truth. His opponents argued
that "the religious gene" is present in all of us and that part of being
human was a desire to search for religious meaning. Dawkins responded: "Speak
for yourself. It is not a part of me. It is not a part of the great majority
of my friends in universities in England and the US and elsewhere." A
poll taken before the debate showed that 826 favored the motion, 681 were
against and 364 didn't know. After the debate the vote was 1,205 for the
motion, 778 opposed and 100 didn't know.
||2007-MAR-29: U.S. Conservative Jewish seminary open to gay students:
The Jewish Theological Seminary (JTS) in New York City --
described as "the flagship seminary of Conservative Judaism,"
announced that it would accept openly gay and lesbian students. A vote by
the JTS faculty produced results similar to a larger opinion survey
conducted among North American Conservative Jews: most professors favored an
inclusive admissions policy. 6 More
Links to religious news sources:
||Links to general religious, conservative Christian, other Christian, and non-Christian news sources is available
elsewhere on this web site.
The following information sources were used to prepare and update the above
essay. The hyperlinks are not necessarily still active today.
Lana Haight, "Rally hears of woman's tubal ligation fight. Debate over
hospital includes fear-mongering, doctor tells crowd," The StarPhoenix,
- "Catholics won't be allowed to run hospital," The Toronto Star,
2007-MAR-08, Page A8.
Pamela Manson, "Judge tosses cybersquatting suit against pro-Mormon group,"
Salt Lake Tribune, 2007-MAR-26, at:
"Dawkins says religion is 'like sucking a dummy'," Times Online,
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/ Podcast available at:
Ruth Gledhill, "We'd be better off without religion," Articles of Faith
blog, Times, 2007-MAR-28, at:
Rebecca Spence, "Conservative Judaismís Flagship Seminary Opens Door to Gays
and Lesbians," Forward, 2007-MAR-30, at:
How you got here:
Copyright © 2007 by Ontario Consultants on Religious
Originally written: 2007-MAR-08
Latest update: 2007-MAR-29
Author: B.A. Robinson
This page translator works on Firefox,
Opera, Chrome, and Safari browsers only
After translating, click on the "show
original" button at the top of this
page to restore page to English.