
Child corporal punishment: spankingTypes of discipline used by parents.
Prediction of future trends
Sponsored link.

What type of discipline do parents use? |
In the 1930's: Surveys showed that over 90% of parents spanked their children,
some three generations ago. Dr.
Benjamin Spock originally endorsed spanking, but then changed his mind in the late 1980's.
|  |
In 1994:
 |
70% of American adults agreed that it is "sometimes necessary to
discipline a child with a good, hard spanking." |
 |
Also in 1994, the National
Committee to Prevent Child Abuse found that only 49% of American adults had hit or
spanked their child in the previous year.
|
|  |
Among religious conservatives: Spanking appears to be still very widely practiced by
Fundamentalist and other Evangelical Christians: |
Focus on the Family, a Fundamentalist Christian group
centered in Colorado surveyed visitors to their web site during late
2003-SEP. Those taking the survey are believed to be overwhelmingly
Fundamentalist or other Evangelical Christian. As such, most probably believe in
the inerrancy of the Bible, and follow the
key verses in the book of Proverbs which advocate
corporal punishment of children. They found that:
 |
91% of those who have children spank them. |
 |
9% do not. 1
|
|  |
In an earlier survey of 2002-JUN, a
slight majority (52.5% vs. 47.5%) expressed the belief that schools should
not be allowed to spank students. 2
|  |
R. Albert Mohler, president of the fundamentalist Christian
Southern Baptist Theological Seminary described spanking as
"the law of God." He dismissed timeouts and grounding as
requiring "a relationship of negotiation between parent and child
-- as if a parent cannot impose one of these techniques
unilaterally. He regards both methods as "...generally more
counterproductive and frustrating than anything else." 3
|
|  |
Among the general population: An
online poll conducted by LKAS TV of Las Vegas, NV, found that
only one in three parents used spanking as their primary method of
discipline. Results were:
 |
33% used spanking |
 |
32% used restriction of privileges |
 |
17% used time outs |
 |
5% used a traditional torture method:
applying hot sauce to
burn the child's tongue
|
 |
1% washed their child's mouth out with
soap |
 |
9% used none of the above. |
|

Future trends: We predict that:  |
The use of corporal punishment --
whipping, spanking, tongue burning, washing the mouth out with
soap, etc. will continue to decrease in North America as public awareness
increases of:
 |
The ineffectiveness of violence as a discipline method compared to other
techniques. |
 |
The long-term hazards of this form of discipline, including clinical
depression, clinical anxiety, drug addiction, and alcohol addiction. |
 |
The link between serious forms of punishment and rage, violent actions,
and other criminal acts among youth.
|
|  |
These methods will continue to be practiced by most religious
conservatives into the foreseeable future, because of their interpretation of
the biblical mandate to use corporal
punishment.
|  |
Fundamentalist and other evangelical parents will be increasingly
concerned about government intrusion into their family's discipline methods.
|  |
North American child protection
services' concern about corporal punishment of all types will
increase.
|  |
Eventually, the U.S. and Canada will
follow the lead of many European countries and declare all forms of
physical punishment of children to be forms of abuse, both in the home and
school. |

References:
-
"Hand Count," Focus on the Family, at:
http://www.family.org/
-
"Hand Count," Focus on the Family, at:
http://www.family.org/
-
R. Albert Mohler, Jr., "Should Spanking Be Banned? Parental Authority Under
Assault," The Christian Post, 2004-JUN-23, at:
http://www.christianpost.com/

Copyright © 1995 to 2009 by Ontario Consultants on
Religious Tolerance
Latest update: 2009-MAY-17
Author: B.A. Robinson

Sponsored link

|